Upon completing the puzzle I got a popup stating:
"Invalid solution. Possible Illegal action reported #code 28741."
This may be due to my popupblocker firing the first time I completed the puzzle. I completed it a third time and got the same error message. No wishpoint has been granted. (I have 0 and I'm below my 60 active days required to spend any)
---
Solved the puzzle in Firefox and it worked. Might be some bug with IE or with my settings... anyways you can disregard this bug report.