I made a list with 5 items that can be created from common and resources. I have other similar ideas and one grand idea.  Should I continue or let this die?

1) Malodorous Potion - when poured on a player, the player loses all their Vitality Points due to fainting

Muddy skull
Fungal mass
Bit of rotten skin
Spicy maggots
Finger nail

26 Toxic plants
3 Toxic Gas
3 Solid stench

100 Uses

2) Vial of Misery - when inhaled by a player, his tongue turns blue and starts to swallow taking the ability to speak for 5 minutes

Wormy driftwood
Handful of Dirt
Musk Incense
Cat's eye
Blue ink

1 Flask of Toxic Extract
13 Unidentified plants
3 Wiiya

30 Uses

3) Phial of Frosted Shards  - this potion will freeze for the next battle a random number creatures of a player on which it is poured

Glass Rose
Broken China Plate
Crystal Bell
Crystalline structure
Glass bead
Piece of frosted glass

13 Tea leaves
3 Raw Glass
3 Crystal

100 Uses

4) Odoriferous brew - this brew is very potent and will allow the player on which it is used to dream of the letters at the scene the caster resides

Bundle of Stems
Pomegranate seeds
Flower petals
Exotic Perfume
Cherry Jam

13 Flowers
3 Gems
1 Lonsdaleite Shards

30 uses
48 hours cooldown

5) Drought of Sorrow - this potion will instantly turn a random number of candies to sticky goop or number of spicy pickles to garbage.

Rusted gears
Scarab beetle fossil
Spider web
Dead fish
Coarse bone dust

13 Toxic Plants
13 Mineral Water
13 Rainwater

30 uses

 

 

 

Nice ideas you got there!

Can't wait for the grand idea..