Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Chapter 1 - Fatso

  Reveal hidden contents

 

Thanks for reading. Any feedback is appreciated as always.

Posted

i am confused on the situation, it would probably help to introduce the MC beforehand and maybe the situation, unless it was your intention to throw the reader into that without it.

also it seems contradicting itself a little? or is it just me?

Posted

I think you have a character there. Needs slightly more work.

Do you plan on writing a bunch of such characters and then make interact? if so, it might be interesting.

Posted
  On 3/3/2019 at 9:39 PM, Josephine said:

I hope you don't mind me being blunt, but it reads like you've been dumped by an overweight woman and are very bitter over it.

Perhaps take a step back and be a little more objective towards the protagonist? (Just a suggestion)

Expand  

Well, its an exaggeration no doubt. Most art is kind of like that otherwise its just plain copying.  I really like Nabokov for example but as a writer being superbly talented aside he is too honest for me..

For this woman I'm thinking someone like "Howard's mother" from BBT. Once you know that kind of person, you can never forget it. And you can never explain it. I'm bitter yes but i want to explain the unexplainable, her thought process.  You might also have noticed i have a massive grudge for the left field. ehm.. that's not the issue here.

You are right about one thing i'm bitter, that's not critical or even important for me here. Also if i take a look an objective view like you said, it wouldn't be it funny, it would turn out she was right about her actions. But who cares? I don't.

Posted
  On 3/4/2019 at 3:26 PM, MaGoHi said:

i am confused on the situation, it would probably help to introduce the MC beforehand and maybe the situation, unless it was your intention to throw the reader into that without it.

also it seems contradicting itself a little? or is it just me?

Expand  

I'm confused as well. I just wrote this for the laughs tbh, you might have noticed grammar mistakes, punctuation errors etc.. This just means i'm super impatient about this character and story. I always wanted to create a super romantic, epic artpiece. Yet real life is often not what one hopes for. I'd almost always want to "show rather than tell" the rest is details. I don't mean to confuse people with super epic, difficult to follow writing style or switching characters after every chapter. I hate those kind of styles.

It definitely does. Yet it doesn't. I don't know, i try to get a handle on bs, with me its not easy at best.

Posted (edited)

Chapter 2 - un named

  Reveal hidden contents

(This is not complete. I couldn't resist to wait until Sunday when i'd planned)

Thanks for the comments. :)

Edited by ignnus
Posted
  On 3/4/2019 at 4:28 PM, Ungod said:

I think you have a character there. Needs slightly more work.

Do you plan on writing a bunch of such characters and then make interact? if so, it might be interesting.

Expand  

Thank you for saying so. I'd just think a good line from time to time or a setting, and i'm not good with dialogues. It's very difficult for me to write normal stuff, not only its boring, i'm bad at it. I'd just think a quote i like (religion is like woman you can never find the depth of either) then let the feeling guide me. Mind that its not the woman here it could as well be the man, i just like the intensity of the person saying it and what caused him to say this.

Possibly, maybe. Like i said, If i write normal characters or stuff, i have to normalize them, which is ehm... boring. I realize certain kind of effort must go into a story, and saying stuff like "its boring" is anathema to some in the art society, yet i write this for myself, so i can laugh and feel good when i read. And others if they do so all the better.

Posted
  On 3/3/2019 at 11:39 PM, Imperius said:

It would help giving her some background story as to why she thinks this way, perhaps a degree in gender studies or men with snouts surrounding her would suffice.

Expand  

I like this answer, noted the degree, very interesting actually i was thinking she was a retired teacher. LOL.  A warning, this novel can't be cool like your art bro. I simply can't draw ever since elementary school no reason to think otherwise for any other. I always like the color orange for some reason though.

Posted

I can't take credit for the fact that I draw well because I didn't choose the talent when I was born, but thank you, although I see every forms of art as 'cool' even if they're not up to anyone's standards. I think what you wrote is cool and humorous, it's clever that you've managed to have people see past what you just did, and I'm still undecided if you're actually serious about this lol.

  On 3/6/2019 at 2:51 PM, ignnus said:

I always like the color orange for some reason though.

Expand  

I hate that Mur has this effect on people.

Posted
  On 3/6/2019 at 4:29 PM, Imperius said:

I can't take credit for the fact that I draw well because I didn't choose the talent when I was born, but thank you, although I see every forms of art as 'cool' even if they're not up to anyone's standards. I think what you wrote is cool and humorous, it's clever that you've managed to have people see past what you just did, and I'm still undecided if you're actually serious about this lol.

I hate that Mur has this effect on people.

Expand  

If only it was Mur, i used to paint entire white paper orange with those pastels then carve it with a knife for the art hours. I was fan of Netherlands for 10 years, cause they used orange on their flag. Still didn't recover from their loss at World Cup to Spain.

Posted
  On 3/6/2019 at 4:29 PM, Imperius said:

I'm still undecided if you're actually serious about this

Expand  

Yeah, kinda. These kind of stuff is not very unique. Shows like Orville or American Dad does the same thing very well. If it can turn out to be more unique than that i'll be happy.

Posted (edited)

That makes more sense. Speaking of uniqueness and feminism (as per this topic's tag), I know of a book where you can get moral values from to add to your repertoire of feminismy allure for your novel. This book is the epitome of moral integrity when it comes to this subject, even the author made hid her real name so as not to be bombarded by people of how good of a human being she is:

j1tqzp4sj8i01.png

Edited by Imperius
Typos
Posted (edited)

 Seems to be an extremely short book. 50 pages? All the better. Got the PDF *cough*,  i'll have a look.   ???? Thanks for the suggestion.

 

Edit: Forgot to add, i have no problem with feminism not really, it was irresponsible for me to add the tag. I'm on the side of woman for whatever the issue is. I just didn't want to add more serious/political tags.

Edited by ignnus
Posted
  On 3/6/2019 at 2:42 PM, ignnus said:

 I'd just think a quote i like (religion is like woman you can never find the depth of either) then let the feeling guide me.

Expand  

That can work, but it gets very messy afterwards. Raw emotion can be entertaining, as long as there is a steel thread of logic.

Anyway, good luck with 'normalization' :))(with writing, just like with everything, the more you do it, the better it gets...or so we hope)

Posted
  On 3/6/2019 at 10:22 PM, Ungod said:

That can work, but it gets very messy afterwards. Raw emotion can be entertaining, as long as there is a steel thread of logic.

Expand  

We have this massive library at where i live, every once in a while I go in, sniff a book out then read a few paragraphs, mostly i'm disappointed, but sometimes there is a book and it grabs my attention, usually the poem books/ analysis or the super technical neurobiology/social studies etc.. anything interesting. Sometimes for me author gets it right while he is not looking. This kind of scavenging is sad and funny at the same time but its the only kind of reading i (can) do. What you said about logic, you may have a point there, but i don't think that's very important. I'd rather see a super symmetrical plot narrated in ridiculous ravings than a solid logic. Though if its steel solid not only its a style hard to achieve that's also kind of interesting on its own. (not technical ofc).

Posted

Chapter 3

  Reveal hidden contents

I was hoping for a lot more content, maybe next week..

Posted

Here's a bit of extra, i planned this tidbit for today, yet somehow forget.

Encounter with a mayor.

  Reveal hidden contents

 

Posted

See, this is what I mean about a thread (if you don't want it to be a steel thread of logic, think of another): a story that goes all over the place is hard to follow and people just give up. 

Writing can't be only fun, you have to work as well...sad, but true.

Posted (edited)

Chapter 2- Unnamed   (Edited some and some additions)

  Reveal hidden contents

 

Edited by ignnus
Posted
  On 3/10/2019 at 3:22 PM, Ungod said:

See, this is what I mean about a thread (if you don't want it to be a steel thread of logic, think of another): a story that goes all over the place is hard to follow and people just give up. 

Writing can't be only fun, you have to work as well...sad, but true.

Expand  

You are right, i assume you are mostly talking about the super serious tone and the weird reactionary sections being totally different.  I will delete every modern terminology here after i finished and replace those as best as i could . I dislike those a lot myself. Other than that i'm not totally disappointed. Plot needs a bit work though. This story won't take place during modern times if and where i can manage, switching to medieval stuff is way more interesting. Factions, and a realistic world, i like those.  Hmmm, Its not so difficult to make up some plot, though that's really doesn't seem like something absolutely necessary at this time. To me at least. I don't know...

Posted
  On 3/10/2019 at 3:37 PM, ignnus said:

Other than that i'm not totally disappointed. Plot needs a bit work though.

Expand  

well, you don't have to be disappointed, because it's a start. some may say it's a bad start, i'd say it's okay, but it's only the start.

the way I see it, I divide books in two big piles: fun (entertainment) and how-to (manuals). There are fun books which last for centuries , because they also contain advice to heed; there are manuals that teach things in a fun way, so you can mix if you so feel.

but when you decide to write, you basically choose from those two, and if it's entertainment, you HAVE to entertain. That's your purpose, and your readers have to be entertained. If it's not entertaining, or it is close to being entertaining, it means you have to work more.

i'm sorry I write on your post so much instead of actual writers (md players) - they could point out more and give better advice...

Posted

Congratulations, Ignnus! May written word bring to you what others could not:)

I read the first part so here goes..

Avoid "ifs" in character introduction. It makes them look weak not by nature but by design, its better to start with more clear insight to their 
capabilities.

It is smart to describe the inner workings of the character first and then get to their agendas, ambition, goals etc.. So reader can follow and justify their action
which always has to be aligned with their inner self. Every "why" has to has an answer sooner rather than later.

Avoid creating a protagonist that is of opposite gender of your own:D Seriously, its far harder that people think.
For some reason female writers are far better in such things than man, to be perfectly objective:)

Most importantly, keep on writing and learn from mistakes. It`s a fascinating journey, Ignnus, never get tired of walking;)

Posted

Chapter 4- The vaults of Hivan

  Reveal hidden contents

Urgh, World Building I guess.

Posted
  On 3/13/2019 at 6:41 PM, Bashaw Steel said:

Congratulations, Ignnus! May written word bring to you what others could not:)

I read the first part so here goes..

Avoid "ifs" in character introduction. It makes them look weak not by nature but by design, its better to start with more clear insight to their 
capabilities.

It is smart to describe the inner workings of the character first and then get to their agendas, ambition, goals etc.. So reader can follow and justify their action
which always has to be aligned with their inner self. Every "why" has to has an answer sooner rather than later.

Avoid creating a protagonist that is of opposite gender of your own:D Seriously, its far harder that people think.
For some reason female writers are far better in such things than man, to be perfectly objective:)

Most importantly, keep on writing and learn from mistakes. It`s a fascinating journey, Ignnus, never get tired of walking;)

Expand  

Thanks a lot, these are not only helpful hints, are also encouragements which i always appreciate. Thanks for reading, and i agree with what you said. Maybe i should kill her and replace her with me :)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Forum Statistics

    17.5k
    Total Topics
    182.2k
    Total Posts
×
×
  • Create New...