Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

MagicDuel Community

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Testing sacrifice altar values

exchange values 119 members have voted

  1. 1. Permanent stats reward (max vit, max vp..)

    • They are Great, can't wait to get it!
      31%
      37
    • Good enough
      24%
      29
    • I can't say yet if they are good or not
      16%
      19
    • Not so good
      16%
      20
    • Very little reward, i wont sacrifice creatures!
      11%
      13
  2. 2. Skills reward (attack, luck, tradesense...)

    • They are Great, can't wait to get it!
      27%
      32
    • Good enough
      37%
      44
    • I can't say yet if they are good or not
      19%
      23
    • Not so good
      11%
      13
    • Very little reward, i wont sacrifice creatures!
      5%
      6
  3. 3. Vitality and value points reward (NOT max values)

    • They are Great, can't wait to get it!
      19%
      23
    • Good enough
      36%
      43
    • I can't say yet if they are good or not
      16%
      19
    • Not so good
      19%
      23
    • Very little reward, i wont sacrifice creatures!
      8%
      10

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

  • Root Admin

Sacrifice altar at the Fenths Press in No Man's Land

The sacrifice altar is under testing. feel free to share your opinion about the exchange stats given for each creature. Don't ask what the logic behind the conversion is.

Also before you judge those values, think about the following things:

- reward cant be to great or players who exchange creatures will get ultra powerfull by just doing that

- players that exchange creatures get a permanent bonus but they still have upgraded creatures so they will be able to upgrade others fast

- permanent stats are more valueble than they seem, for example max value points can make a difference between upgrading a creature or not or beeing able to buy a certain weapon.

- honor reward can be converted to wins for your creatures by attacking weak player just for the wins, ...and wins for the creatures means possible upgrades

- principle are not yet used. Each sacrifice altar gived different principle rewards!!!

- max level creatures can give different reward based on many things, so there is no cap to what a creature can give as reward, however a high level creature might be more usefull as it is than sacrificing it.

- compare rewards to the rewards given by the story after waiting 24hours

Whatever you say, try to make sense and not just shout you dont like it.

  • Replies 65
  • Views 12.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

my lvl 4 archer gives me 3k value at the current time while my lvl 5 archer gives 2k. Also the 2nd lvl of elementals just after egg only gives honor when it takes nothing to upgrade it,

i can understand why the lvl 4 vs lvl 5 archer gives more value - the lvl 5 has a lower attack score. but the lvl 5 give better overall bonus' so it all balances out anyway.

The thing about the lvl 2 elemental giving honor is kind of off though. Like Shadowice said, it took nothing but a 3 day waiting period to get it to lvl 2. Perhaps there should be only a very low vit and val (not max) for this, and the honor reward comes into play when they hit lvl 3. otherwise this can be too easily exploited.

its very interesting. to get the best stat boost you need to work at it, which is good. and i agree with the lvl two elemental it only takes a few days to hatch one thats definitely going to be exploited. you gonna see a lot of people with a lot of honor.

but other then that its looking pretty good.

i have a question, can the vit and VP reward from sacrificing (not max vit or VP) go over you maximum?

(only in between ticks like from winning fights)

maybe limit it to one sacrifice per regeneration, then you cant just store up value by buying 20 barren souls then sacrificing them all at once and getting 4000 value points.

Well i dont think thats necessary, since a lower level player would take so long to get 20 barren souls, and use up 8000 value points in doing so, i dont see the need to limit sacrifices. But thats just my opinion...

Just imagine players with 4k of VP that go rampage and buy BS when they don't need the VP and then when they have a creature to upgrade they will go and sell all the creatures they bought before and gain huge values of VP to upgrade the creatures => This is not OK.

If you need just some VP, let's say 300 or so to upgrade your creature I think it's just fine to sell a creature so you can upgrade another one, that is if you can't find anyone to fight and get some VP but stocking up on VP(low lvl creatures) doesn't sound right to me.

I agree with what has been said

And is it possible to get luck,trade sense etc by sacrificing? because i wouldn't have got any for one of my creatures

Why it depends only on creature's level?

Shouldn't it be depended on much more values, such as exp gained, wins gained, ages lived..?

Actually yeah, i see your point, but an alternative could be limiting the VP so that it cannot pass max when sacrificing. But you guys are right, something should be done.

I didn't see any that gave luck or trade, but i did see attack and defense...perhaps with certain creatures at certain levels those other stats are an option.

Btw, Manu.

I need 1 more optin to answer:

"They are too much (uber). They totally crashes the balance"

I would take that one :)

I took another look at some of the rewards you can gain and spotted a problem.

The vitality and value seem ok, but the stat increases could prove to be a problem.

I would suggest moving the decimal point over a space or two. Instead of getting +1 Defense (or whatever stat) make it .1 or even .01 instead. otherwise people will be walking around with mini-gods in next to no time.

Actually I don't necessarily agree on that, because you need a lot of age from lvl 3 and up on most of the important creatures, so I don't really think .1 or .01 values will do. I don't really see why I would want to exchange my time invested (age) in values so small when I can use them in fights and get much more.

If it will be like that I only see that as an losing xp feature and nothing more.

.1 and .01 were to show the decimal place for some stats. take a principal for instance: exchanging a certain powerful creature will give you 200 or so points in a certain principal, and on stats - turning in some creatures will give 30 attack or defense. move the decimal point to reflect more realistic stat bonus' instead of a 200 cyclicity you would get 20 or 2. and instead of 30 attack, you'd get 3 or .3

And we all know a gain of 3 in any stat is HUGE. that is bigger than what you'd get from doing 24 hr meditation in the story

i didn't literally mean .1 and .01

Altar is now functional. Be aware that the sacrifice button directly sacrifices the creature without any further confirmation. Also the reward vales changed a lot.

How come there are no rewards what so ever for elementals I?

  • Author
  • Root Admin

Shadar ... elemental I takes only age to upgrade. Level I and II creatures offer little to nothing as reward. They usualy offer temporary stats such as valuepoints and vitality, and are ment only to allow you to get rid of the low level creatures you dont use anymore, especialy with the new creature number limit in place.

High level creatures offer inscrrease to permanent stats.

warning...sacriice takes 10 actionpoints, so if you sacrifice them to get extra VP be sure you wont remain stuck in that scene without action points until next regeneration ...because you will also loose extra vit and vp at next regen.

Shadar ... elemental I takes only age to upgrade. Level I and II creatures offer little to nothing as reward. They usualy offer temporary stats such as valuepoints and vitality, and are ment only to allow you to get rid of the low level creatures you dont use anymore, especialy with the new creature number limit in place.

High level creatures offer inscrrease to permanent stats.

warning...sacriice takes 10 actionpoints, so if you sacrifice them to get extra VP be sure you wont remain stuck in that scene without action points until next regeneration ...because you will also loose extra vit and vp at next regen.

But the elementals that you pay for and upgrade to level 1 from the egg still have no turn in value, not even temporary?

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 17.5k
  • Total Posts 182.2k

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.