Far away in a place where people knew how to mediate problems there was a meeting.

• If someone's being an asshat then let's punish them
  • How do we punish them?
    • Embargo!
    • Ban them from our quests!
    • Add them to our ignorelists!
  • But wait how long do we do this for?
    • Well we can't do it forever can we?
    • No we can't! But how do we know when to stop?
    • I guess if they start being a part of the community again...
    • Good idea! But will they have a chance to?
    • Perhaps not depleting would be a step in the right direction...
    • Yes!
  • Guys guys guys wait! Most of this is subjective, how do we prevent that from ruining stuff?
    • Majority rules?
    • Take turns acting as a sort of executive-officer-for-the-week but all decisions of the officer have to be ratified at a bi-weekly meeting by a simple majority but in the...
    • Stop quoting monty python!
    • Hey, he's onto something but how would we only allow members of the organization to vote?
    • We could send eachother letters... but I guess we couldn't be anonymous
    • Have the votes only public WITHIN our ranks
    • What if I leakem?
    • Then we punish you!
    • Do I get kicked out too?
    • Well.. umm yessss?

 

Hello my name is Rophs and I'm going to form a dumb club where we don't like asshats. We'll ban them from our quests and not trade with them. Because it's my club I can decide if you can join or not but eventually we'll probably get more organized. Let's start with a simple definition of asshat... somebody who depletes resources. But the 1/1 memorystones shouldn't count. Nor should other 1/1 resources. That's it for now but if the people in my club think you're a buttface when we'll punish you!

 

I'm the only member right now...

Closed, This is the wrong way to go about this.

And yet a discusdion about "social solution" and what to do is much needed....

You havent read any of your emails Mur...