Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

MagicDuel Community

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Regarding the current state of things

Featured Replies

Hello.

I figured I should write an update on what happened so far and what I'm currently doing. Some of these are private LR matters but since for whatever reason people are really interested... I say why not publish it.
After my inauguration, I sent Mur some requests that I felt like could be granted instantly / without much planning. Here's how it went:

1.) Access to Hollow Den + Path Keeper + Lore Sanctum + Aia's Retreat
This went relatively well, there's now a LR king item that grants access to the first 2. Access was also granted to the other two, but with a caveat: it consumes all of my AP just like stepping inside Necro. The king should have access to all scenes (that are not currently in development) so this shouldn't be controversial.

2.) I asked for a spell that according to some of my contacts all previous monarchs had.
But, it doesn't seem like such a thing exists so I just made myself look stupid. This is partly why I'd like to think more carefully about what I ask for in the future.

3.) Make the Loreroot back entrance a one way street
(It annoyed me that people can just come in through there right at the land weapon control room.) This one got denied, as it's a wish item and all lands have two entrances for lore reasons apparently.

4.) I asked for an explanation about how LR's land weapon works.
(The one that has its control room inside Wasp's Totem) Turns out it doesn't work at all as it was never fully finished. Mur told me he's willing to do it and what it should do can be discussed, but warned me that once done he won't change it again.
Which is why this is getting delayed. This is a historical opportunity, and what I do now will have longstanding consequences for Loreroot. I'm currently looking for info about how it was meant to work in the first place.

5.) Remove Ledah's nonsense from the throne room
I think here he misunderstood what I wanted (removing the cringey subtitle) and instead monarchs got tools that can remove placed items within their land. Which is practical so I didn't complain.

Other stuff

Auditing the treasury
This was the easiest audit ever because it is empty. This is not a slight against previous leadership because from what I understand this is a new feature.
Just wanted to be transparent.
It has room for 20 creatures and 20 items (probably item stacks) and apparently the crits put in there age normally. However, Chewett suggested we ask Mur to clarify the rules governing its usage before using it for anything.

Things that are currently work in progress

Land weapon
As I said above, currently gathering info.

Writing Loreroot's history
I reached out to jakubhi with this one as he has already done research on the topic. I don't necessarily want to dump the responsibility on him, but if he already has stuff written then we shouldn't work in parallel.
With that said, we could make this part of his role as a librarian - maybe a set of books in Lore Manor that are editable with the librarian role? If he wants.

Addressing the resource situation
There was a lot of discussion about depletion lately so I don't want to repeat myself too much. But basically, I think the core of the issue is that there just aren't enough resources in Loreroot to cover the increased demand.
I talked to Chewett about this, he said him and Aia had some plans regarding this back in the day. But from what I understand that plan is bigger than Loreroot and if that is so I do not want to move on my own. Ideally we should hand in a joint petition. He'll dig up the plans next week, we'll see how we can proceed from there.

The future of CotE
Children of the Eclipse has not one but two active members, which makes it the most populous alliance in Loreroot currently... I reached out to both Death Ray and jakubhi to learn how they see the future of the alliance. Ideally I'd like to make one of them the nominated leader in Aia's absence, and figure out whether they need something for their role (talks are currently ongoing, I didn't have much time).

Things currently on the back burner

Killing tool for Loreroot
This was one of my big plans before the election, but I already said it is a long term goal and might be tricky. What I didn't consider, and what multiple people have warned me about is that - should Mur grant us one - it could lead to, as they say in the other world, mass proliferation...
Which is something to consider. However, there are more than one way of getting one... We know for a fact it can be wished for (Else), and in can be created in the Forge if one is important enough (Ledah).
I still haven't decided how I'll achieve this, but for now I'm just trying to avoid doing something I'll regret later.

Resource policy / guidance for LR citizens
I wanted to write these too but the exact policy would depend on whether or not we can increase the amount of resources in the land, and in what way. Currently I see no point in harassing people for gathering down to 1 when everyone does it pretty much, and the average resource node gets below 66% from 2-3 gathers from someone skilled enough. As such, I'd rather avoid writing / trying to enforce a policy for something that is about to change anyway (if everything goes well).

The national drink of Loreroot
Admittedly one of the less important matters, but it's something I'd like to create eventually.
However, with the recent addition of the treasury I think we could make this even more practical... Aside from getting drunk, we could even sell these and possibly other crafts to fill up the treasury. Imagine like a dedicated wine cellar, which could work similarly to the famous muffin man. But I maintain that people should be able to create their own too. Just brainstorming here...

The situation with Seigheart

I feel like I need to address this too because according to some he is being persecuted for running for king even though I said I won't do that.

He is not being persecuted for that, this is my reaction to all the other stuff he did. Let me give you some context on how things got to this point:

When I returned to the realm a couple months ago Seigheart was busy depleting Loreroot. To be fair, he wasn't the only one doing it. But when confronted about it he denied doing it even after I provided screenshots, or in some cases he said he doesn't have a choice because someone else would take the resources if he didn't. Which is logic I can't agree with but okay. Still ,there is SOME merit to it given the shortage of resources, see above. So I just let it slide for the most part.

Then of course he started calling me useless for not punishing behavior that he himself partook in (even though I didn't really have any way of doing so at the time).

Then one day Death Ray (one of our own citizens) took something triggering a trap after which Seigheart and Ledah proceeded to give him stat damage. Because when someone does something questionable the solution isn't to have a talk with them, but outright stat damage.

Some time after that when I caught him depleting something to zero I gave him some of his own medicine - a good lockinchaos spell I recently acquired. Admittedly, he too 3 pieces of lumber from a scene where the maximum amount is 3, so he couldn't have collected it otherwise. But according to him, one shouldn't ask questions and just punish people so I did just that. And man, he didn't like that at all:

pmfile (1).jpg

I'd like to note that at this point Death Ray and I both voted for him in the citizenship poll anyway (I think his crafting gig is beneficial to the realm overall), but it kept failing for mysterious reasons.

Then the royal election arrived, he started asking questions from the candidates which I felt was beneficial. He sort of misunderstood(?) some of the things I said but I figured maybe that's just his interpretation. Then he signed up himself and used his flawed understanding(?) of my position to springboot his campaign saying that nobody has a plan (I evidently do).

Then he claimed I threatened him with destroying the Crafters alliance in case he runs for king, which is an outright lie. I did threaten him afterward to piss him off but consider how weightless the threat is - the Crafters have been deserted for a decade+ and Mur already said he won't bring it back because we have the forge for such purposes now. It is merely a logo on LR's alliances page.

What I did mean however is that I would never let him join Loreroot. I did say that I won't prosecute anyone for running for king, but frankly it was never meant to be a blanket immunity for all kinds if disingenuous and backstabbing behavior. And as you can see this is only the tip of the iceberg.

I just don't want to put up with this, and above all I don't want to be held responsible when he has one of his episodes in the future.

If this is persecution then so be it, I stand by what I said.

Edited by Nep

As I already explained to you, my actions were based on incomplete information, some of it fed to me by someone else. I own that. I should have asked questions before acting, and Death Ray deserved a conversation rather than stat damage. I've said that before and I'll say it again here.

As for my reaction to being Locked in Chaos: between you, BSR, and Fang, it has happened dozens of times in the past month. I have limited time to actually sit down and do things in MD, so when I got locked again, for three pieces of lumber from a scene whose max is three, I lost my temper. That doesn't excuse what I wrote, but it is the context you left out.

On the election: I ran because I believed I had something to offer, not to attack you. If I misread your position, then the right answer is to clarify it publicly, and I'll gladly correct myself. To be clear, I never said that you said it to me.

You've made it clear I won't be welcome in Loreroot, and that's your call to make. I'll keep doing what I've always done: crafting, helping new players, and building things for the realm. I'd rather we move forward than keep relitigating this.

I will have the Maker's Circle with or without a badge.

I could go through each point one by one, but the summary is this:

  • You haven't prioritised your public pledges, which didn't really give you anything, and instead made new ones when you got the role which gave you something.

  • A lack of understanding rudimentary concepts (lands having multiple entrances) and seeming to take advice from equally ignorant "contacts".

  • Asking Mur to do something you could do yourself - remove the 2 locations I named - named in a way such that they don't break the rules.

  • You have penalised your rivals, which you said you wouldn't - I am not defending Seig, but if you knew this about him, why make that pledge? Likewise, my 2 location tags, that is really your priority...

  • You have kept calling people names - clowns, cringe, and whilst you post Seig's poor choice of words, I note you did not mention your own that you posted on the forum - which I will not repeat here for decency's sake.

  • You made a stupid pledge which you now realise is stupid - why you ever thought proliferating killing tools in such a way was a good idea is beyond me. Not a good sign, however.

I will also say, whilst other people may be doing things along the lines of what you want, to rely on them is a fools errand - that is why things never end up happening in MD, because people are relying or leaving it up to someone else when they could come with their own fleshed out ideas. It does not matter what Chew and Aia have discussed, make your own ideas whilst you wait.

You asked why I cared so much or something along those lines. I truly don't care for Loreroot itself one bit, but I have seen so many people come and go, rulers amongst them.

You have an important role now, and with Loreroot in the state it is, it is going to live or die with you at the moment. I expect people to keep to their word, try to minimise hypocrisy, and overall not be extremely objectively stupid, particularly when it comes to the choices they make.

Thank you for posting the full list of your initial requests, that was good I will say.

As an aside, you don't need to be honest or transparent if you don't want to be - I twist words and am as opaque as anything else. However, look at the reputation my character has, and ask yourself if that is the one you want as King.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 17.7k
  • Total Posts 183.8k

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.