Champion Fighter-*Clock Master*
Elite Villain-Jester
MD Troll-Eon

Edited December 8, 201114 yr by ignnus

I believe Dragual Monarth and Brulant are of Necrovion? I'm sure Azull is.

[quote]

Outstanding service to MD
*[b]Brulant[/b] (+[b]Dragual Monarth[/b])

Golden protector
*[b]Azull[/b] (+Sasha Lilias, [b]Dragual Monarth[/b], Maebius)
[/quote]

You should have asked people to tell their citizenship before nominating people, and probably telling citizenship of the nominated person.

Also, do the rules allow for one of the people to drop citizenship of a land, just to be able to be nominated by his "previous" fellow citizens?
Because there are several examples of land changing, even jailtime (nadrolski, tho he might have been released, I don't remember), which makes them eligible for nominations.

For example, Jester was the king of Necrovion, up till recent. Some people have influence in certain lands like they are their citizens (Pipstickz with Necro and Tribunal), because they actually were before.
The rule is so made in rush, and it sucks, plainly. It has major flaws, doesn't take a lot of things in consideration.

Dragual Monarth is not (and has never been) a citizen of Necrovion, Princ.
I am, though

Edited December 8, 201114 yr by Brulant

My bad, then, Brulant. I was sure I saw Necrovion citizen tag on him long time ago...

Thanks for the nomination but I'm ineligible for that award. (I think)

This account was opened on (DD.MM.YYYY H:M): [b]05.12.2010 08:32[/b]

Activity days: [b]55% [/b] (A total of 203 out of 369 days)

(I left MD for a couple of months shortly after creating my account)

Edited December 8, 201114 yr by Falronn

[quote name='Brulant' timestamp='1323369320' post='97500']
Dragual Monarth is not (and has never been) a citizen of Necrovion, Princ.
I am, though
[/quote]
He associates with Necrovion though:
[url="http://magicduel.invisionzone.com/topic/10360-necrovion-scholar-of-necrovion-history/"]http://magicduel.invisionzone.com/topic/10360-necrovion-scholar-of-necrovion-history/[/url]
But by no means should this remove his ability to nominate Necrovion citizens, since there is nothing in this rule about possible future citizens, or friends of citizens.

I know, thus my pointing out of the ridiculous and incomplete rule

Yes, well, apparently we need consensus to be rid of it, even though I saw nothing of a consensus to instate it.

I think its a daft and unfair rule, since the people most likely to see the sort of things that would get you nominated are people of your own land.
It is also an unfair restriction, as people without a land affiliation are still able to nominate each other.
The lands all also have different sizes of population.

I don't think it makes any sense to differentiate between lands during the nominations phase. I do think there may potentially be merit for taking it into consideration during the voting stage, however during nominations its just silly and ill thought out. As has been pointed out over and over, there are far too many things such a rule doesn't take into consideration.

we nominate the people good near to your heart

Well, I've already said that I'm against this rule. I nominated from all lands, the people that I speak to almost every day. I can't nominate someone I don't know. It just so happens that I know a few more people from my land than the others.

It's not mandatory that we all nominate someone. Simply just don't post in this topic.

[quote name='Falronn' timestamp='1323371559' post='97504']
Thanks for the nomination but I'm ineligible for that award. (I think)

This account was opened on (DD.MM.YYYY H:M): [b]05.12.2010 08:32[/b]

Activity days: [b]55% [/b](A total of 203 out of 369 days)

(I left MD for a couple of months shortly after creating my account)
[/quote]
Your account was created after the nominations had ended last year, thus you are eligible for this year's awards.

I was asked to post here. Thanks to whoever nominated me!

This account was opened on (DD.MM.YYYY H:M): [b]01.02.2011 17:48
[/b]Activity days: [b]98% [/b] (A total of 304 out of 311 days)

Rookie of the year: Guillak
Elite Villain: Tipu

Prime Quest Maebius

Top Techie Chewett T

the Golden Protector Shemhazaj

Elite Villain: Tipu

Most Addicted- Eon

Edited December 9, 201114 yr by ZenTao

Most Addicted: Eon
Rookie of the year: Passant the Weak
Prime Quest: Fyrd Argentus
Pre-eminent Role Player: Awiiya

Best Beautification
[color=#ff0000]*Dragonrider (+Zleiphneir)[/color]- his topic is awesome if you ask me, has anyone seen it? It may be fantasy, but it's still awesome to even be dedicated enough to make such a chain.


Elite Evil Villain of the Year
*Jester (+Sasha Lilias, Awiiya, Maebius)(-Arkken)- simply biggest disturbance ever.


Fossil of the year
For the player who has been around so long they have turned into a fossil. The player must be visibly active over the past year, and on the veterans list in game.
I would nominate Akasha if I could here. Since I can't chewy. He won before, but he IS the old one, ancient before people joined mostly.

Most Addicted
For the player who just can't leave MD for more than a minute without needing a fix.
*Eon (+Zleiphneir, Lashtal, ZenTao)
In terms of felt activity, Eon.


Outstanding Service to MD
*Eon - one has to admit, big changes in regards to mp5.


Pre-eminent Role Player
*Zleiphneir- well he's lazing around all day, but dedicated. Might swap to Awiiya next year or year after.

Rookie of the year
*Guillak [185 active days, 29th May 2011] - not much to say, he made enough of an impression to me.

Top Techie
*Fyrd Argentus- ignoring chew's scripts which I cannot assess because I'll never see them, fyrd's lost path was the best coded event I think.

Outstanding Service to MD
Seigheart

Helper of the year
Mya Celestia

Pre-eminent Role Player
Awiiya


Elite Evil Villain of the Yea
Tipu

Champion Fighter
xrieg

Best Spell Caster
Amoran

Edited December 10, 201114 yr by ZenTao

any update on voting starting? was supposed to start on friday

Marvolo : Fossil of the Year

Maebius : Rookie of the Year

Shemhazaj : Golden Protector

Chewett : Helper of the Year

Sasha lilias : Best Spell Caster (annoying one ^^ )

So what happened with this??

Any news?

I believe I know what happened with this.. No one asked or argued the point of not being able to nominate people of your own land. It limits the nominations, and gives the person nominating only a certain range of people to nominate. So perhaps people just ran out of nominations? I believe the way this is set up is a complete farce, and honestly.. I don't like the way it's being run.

No one asked for the limitation, and people have argued it clearly, so why is it in place? Do you really need 20 people to say "this is stupid" before you decide that it's a stupid idea?

http://magicduel.invisionzone.com/topic/8745-md-anual-awards-feedback/

I wonder why nobody thought it was stupid all year long...
In fact, it seemed that nobody had any point FOR in-group nominations, but Chewie and Bun Bun got a nice load of rep for talking AGAINST it.

You believe incorrectly, Amoran.

It was not my waiting on more nominations, I had forgotten how busy I was going to be this past series of days when I set the schedule up.
Dates will be appropriately shifted when voting starts.