Reputation - Like Buttons

[dst]

No Chewy, we can't unless we are logged out. Check with Mods as well. Maybe they can and only commoners can't.

[Grido]

yeah, I can see all the likes

[Change]

yeah, I can see all the likes

Same here.

[Tom Pouce]

if i am login, i only see an button "like this"

if i am logout, i see if some did like the post but cant push an "like this" button as i am not login

and i remark also that if i am log out and see who as like an post its if ther are many like votes seeing onlly the 3 to 4 first

ex.  see that written    "Peace, Phantom Orchid, Neno Veliki and 5 others like this"

I dont know if its what you wanted to do Chewett
 

Edited May 7, 2013 by Tom Pouce

[Burns]

+1 to mod can see likes, didn't even think you couldn't with a 'normal' account

[Miq]

Indeed can't see when logged in. But i consider it a feature.

 

Also i want the downvote button public or not.

 

Miq

 

[Laphers]

I think I prefer the +/- system but I do think that people should be accountable for the reputation they are giving others so making it public is a good thing.

 

If it were changed back but not made public then I would suggest putting in a counter to state that the rep score is made up of # votes. I personally don't really care about the post's score but would rather see how many people thought that a post was worth repping up or down.  If it is -2 but only 2 people voted on it then it's not really a worry.  If it's -2 and 20 people voted then I know that the post is worth looking at because a lot of people felt it was worth repping. Maybe it's just me but I'd rather see that one of my posts was repped 9 times rather than seeing a post was +1.

[BFH]

If a person can be enought civilized to accept that people are different and that everyone isn't a 100$ bill to be liked by everyone then he should obviously never post, speak or even communicate...

 

Hence I would love to see who voted against me and in favor of me (would be cool to have old system back with that "mod" feauture added to everybody...

 

While I personally think like that... Not everybody is that open hence poor Chew is like between many walls. Go Wookie go, keep up experimenting :P

[Tom Pouce]

As it is now, that one need to be log off to see the rating i find it ackward

 

so i dont like that

 

since i wont bother except to look if an special posting as rating

 

its like that rating dont exist anymore for me, i look the forum login ... so i dont see any rating

and that way i am really not thinking to rate things ... well maybe some exceptionnal posting would warrant me to look at rating and then switch back to login and rate

 

so i in general dont like how its made now

 

reading forum twice , its not fun ...

 

either make no rating at all, or make it one see rating and can vote login thats my suggestion

Edited May 9, 2013 by Tom Pouce

[Fyrd Argentus]

I liked the old system.  It had no consequences, and was quite entertaining, in its own way.

[Chewett]

There is another solution. No reputation at all.

[DARK DEMON]

Isn't making rep public a solution?

[Zyrxae]

Udgard, I've wondered that too, and resolved the issue by attempting to vote as if I couldn't see the rep of the post in question. The effectiveness of this strategy increases with the transparency of the reputation system (see below).

--

Might a poll help decide this? Something along the lines of:

 

1) Pick the option you most prefer. Transparent means everyone can see how everyone votes, opaque means only you can see how you voted. The current system is translucent: you can view who likes what, but it's a hassle to do so unless you're a moderator.

• "Like" system, transparent
• "Like" system, translucent (current)
• "Like" system, opaque
• +/- rep system, transparent
• +/- rep system, opaque (previous)
• +/- rep system with +reps transparent and -reps opaque
• +/- rep system with +reps opaque and -reps transparent (Rhaegar's suggestion)
• no rep at all

2) Select your second most preferred option.

[list as above]

 

3) Select your least favorite option.

[list again]

 

4) Select your second least favorite option.

[guess what goes here]

 

Or it could be third favorite instead of second least favorite or whatever other changes seem appropriate.

 

Vote for whether you'd like a poll by +/- repping this post (à la last year's development focus) -- ah wait, no, we can't do that using this system. Hm.

[Chewett]

We are confined to using the system that they produce, the reason you cannot see who liked when not logged in is a BUG because this forum software is incredibly poor.

[Kaya]

I don't like likes, but people should be willing to take responsibility for their votes. Therefore I'll vote for a transparent +/- rep system.

[Ackshan Bemunah]

Seems the +/- transparent both was and is a clear dominator.

 

On a side note, it seems the issue with having to log out to see likes is fixed now.