August 31Aug 31 comment_206462 I have been thinking about a possible direction for the Caretakers, particularly in light of their historical association with death and preservation. Rather than treating these as separate responsibilities, I think they can be brought together through the idea of memory and what remains after loss.Death in the realm is rarely permanent. People, alliances, even lands may wither only to return many years later. What is lost in the process may therefore be something subtler and more delicate: a role, a relationship, a place, a practice, a memory, or simply the way something once was.I have proposed a new alliance statement to the Grand Duke and now I would like to make it public and hear from you. I believe this could be a good direction to move beyond the focus on death that has defined much of the Caretakers' identity for so many years.The Caretakers attend to what has been lost, and to the imbalance its absence leaves behind. A Caretaker preserves the relationship between what is here and something that is no longer fully present.A void is not necessarily something that must be repaired: it may be acknowledged, filled, or sometimes, even, caused. A Caretaker may place a memory, a remnant, a ritual, a name, a place, or an act within that void and see what happens. The result may restore, transform, disturb, or create something entirely new. We tend to what follows.To preserve one continuity may be to disrupt another; to fill one void may create another elsewhere. Caretaking does not place one outside the things it changes. In this sense, the Caretakers can also be understood as seekers of motion. Not because movement is always good, but because that which has been lost may leave behind a stillness worth disturbing.I would welcome your thoughts, objections and suggestions. Let us see what it stirs. Report
August 31Aug 31 Root Admin comment_206463 After a long thoughtful discussion with Aelis I agree with this move and will, once a short period of public discussion occurs, put this forward to Mur to action. Report
August 31Aug 31 comment_206464 As the last leader of the alliance I think that Aelis would indeed lead the Caretakers in an interesting direction, and therefore support his leadership bid. Report
October 3Oct 3 comment_206921 I agree with the proposal from Aelis. But just for easy reference, following is the copy of the original post from phantasm.I think the caretakers are more a Graveyard type caretakers then the trim the hedges caretaker. I don’t see much of a point to an alliance that is just a face for a land. It should have a deep rooted sense of something it wants to accomplish. What better person to lead such an organization than me. I am slightly undead, have a love for finding trouble to get into, and think that an alliance such as this should be able to War as well as tend. What is a hedge trimmer going to do in battle? Gravediggers, throughout history, have been well known for taking matters into their own hands. Doing dark experiments, finding fresh corpses when none are available, and keeping the dead where they belong. I have a shrewd and keen mind, am more than willing to pull battle if needed, and have an overall love for things shady and dark dealings.I also have strong feelings towards guarding what I think needs guarded. I also have a great respect and would demand a great respect for togetherness. I have never liked the idea of people jumping in and out of an alliance. Once you are in you are in, and once you are out you are out. If people decide to apply, and I decide to accept, they will not be allowed to jump around freely with their tag. Alliances are a bond, a family, meant to care and watch after each other, and the lands they hold at ALL times.The CaretakersPurpose of the Caretakers--The underlying purpose I think should be about death. Just as a caretaker would tend to the gravestones and prepare the dead for their travels, that should be the role. As I think the Tribunal will be about monuments and pieces of great people in MD gone by, they will tend to the research and care of these illustrious names, and keeping a good care over the lands and the actions that hold within.Role of the Caretakers---To preserve and glorify names of the most memorable people of MD’s past, and to an extent, present. To all great sick and twisted caretakers, life wouldn't be complete without a little death and mayhem. Darkness would be their cloak. Death would be their sword. Fate would be their mind. Sometimes it is needed to hasten the process in which things happen. Caretakers have a love for the end of things. Sometimes the end of things do not come as fast as they would like, so they….hasten things. I think the alliance would be classified not as good or evil but as Chaotic.To walk through the lands with a shovel in their hand. The self proclaimed judge and jury of whatever they feel to be the judge of. Is it any more evil to see who should be judged anymore than a knight would judge who is wrong or right? Is it any more wrong to bury the not-so-dead for a little pay than to burn your enemies alive for the sake of religion?“Grave digger…when you dig my grave…please make it shallow…so that I can feel the rain”Structure of AllianceMaster Chief- The Leader. The man with the master plan. Responsible for leading activities and making sure the alliance itself runs smooth. Approves or Denies Plans set forth by the Grave DiggersGrave Digger- Right and Left hand seats. Those deemed worthy by the Master Chief to carry out plans approved for action. Usually carries out secret plans that are only known between the upper management. Runs activities set forth in the land and keeps watch over the lower levels of the allianceScribe- Responsible for keeping logs of meetings. Also keeps a record of festivities, duties carried out by the alliance, and a secret log of the things carried out that no one knows.Concotionist- The thinker. Thinks up ideas for activities and festivities. Is not aware of the more secret of workings though may be an unknowing participant in its actions. An active role in anything and everything within the alliance, with the exception of certain plans held privilege to the top 3 of the alliance.Caretakers- The grunts. The 5 general population members of the alliance. Carries out all propaganda and general actions of the Alliance. Those of the position to care after the land and the things concerning the alliance outside the land. All around fun people and held accountable for the smooth running of the land. Report
October 11Oct 11 comment_207052 Aelis should have been leader if not for him leaving for Soldiers of the Inner Sun... Rather than that pesky Ledah character causing all kinds of trouble like forcing me to deplete Loreroot and kill Aeoshattr. I support this new direction in the alliance statement. Let me leave some passages I think about often and are related ..."In the quiet, heavy amber of the fading afternoon, when the shadows stretch like tired limbs across the floorboards of the empty house, I find myself standing at the threshold of a memory that I have spent years trying to pave over, realizing finally that some ghosts are not residents of the places we leave behind, but are carried within the very marrow of our own bones, refusing to stay buried no matter how deep the silence we craft around them."The horizon is a line where sky and earth meet, serving to gather all our prior movement into a single, coherent vision of a journey defined not by its destination but by the expanding scale of the view, a sustained line of thought where the tension between the reach of the hand and the reach of the eye becomes the engine of meaning, proving that the most complex structures we build—whether they are paths across a continent or sentences across a page—are ultimately evidence of a controlled escalation toward a truth that remains, beautifully and necessarily, just out of reach. Report
November 8Nov 8 Author comment_207597 On 8/31/2026 at 10:11 AM, Aelis said:I have been thinking about a possible direction for the Caretakers, particularly in light of their historical association with death and preservation. Rather than treating these as separate responsibilities, I think they can be brought together through the idea of memory and what remains after loss.Death in the realm is rarely permanent. People, alliances, even lands may wither only to return many years later. What is lost in the process may therefore be something subtler and more delicate: a role, a relationship, a place, a practice, a memory, or simply the way something once was.I have proposed a new alliance statement to the Grand Duke and now I would like to make it public and hear from you. I believe this could be a good direction to move beyond the focus on death that has defined much of the Caretakers' identity for so many years.I would welcome your thoughts, objections and suggestions. Let us see what it stirs.For historical purposes, I would invite everyone to read what I proposed here when the alliance was without a leader. I dare anyone to say we haven't worked towards what is written here. Do note that the proposal was explicitly titled "A New Path" and was approved.Then comes someone who only keeps track of changes when it suits them, and chooses to disband everything we have built because of technicalities. They say there were no revivals. I say a land was revived (and not at the click of a button). Since when MagicDuel has become so literal?I tried to reason and be polite, and what I got in return was the opposite. This is very unfortunate and it certainly says more about the other party than about our merit as Caretakers. Report
November 8Nov 8 comment_207598 Was anyone doing much anything in the last year? According to that logic everyone should be disbanded. Report
November 8Nov 8 comment_207601 I would like to add some historical context. The Caretakers were founded at a time when the dead mechanic as we know it did not yet exist. The only way to die was during a torch contest, and you would be revived automatically afterwards. The Caretakers have also never been servants of the dead. I will quote Phantasms original proposal:To all great sick and twisted caretakers, life wouldn't be complete without a little death and mayhem. Darkness would be their cloak. Death would be their sword. Fate would be their mind.And Caretakers have a love for the end of things. Sometimes the end of things do not come as fast as they would like, so they….hasten things.The later in particular being relevant. If anything, under Aelis the Caretakers have returned to their original purpose and him and the other Caretakers being punished for it is a great injustice. Report
November 8Nov 8 comment_207603 First of all I want to express my utmost sadness and indignation concerning recent events. What could have been a beginning of a new exciting chapter - ended in an unexpected and in my oppinion pointless event of disbanding. I admire how Caretakers stand proud and dignant amidst of it all. That shows me, that badge or no badge - Caretakers are more than alive. They understand that end of things inevitably means new beginning.As for the new path - I would propose you take a broader look at the concept of caretaking itself. In its broader meaning is caretaking - process of maintaining, managing and securing something. Starting from there you can choose a direction that fits you most. You could for example focus on maintaining of values (material vs immaterial), maintaining of balance in broader sense or some aspect of it. Whatever it is - you have my support. Report
November 8Nov 8 comment_207620 Claim 1: this was part of a larger quote that was mostly sarcasm mixed with talking up Ledah's love for mischief. Perhaps one of my favorite accomplishments, killing Aeoshattr was a targeted message that didn't require language to get the point across. The point was taken immediately, the Necrovions thought they had a monopoly on death, and I showed them that wasn't something they should use lightly. My main point was not actually that they were killing, as I killed as well, rather the manner in which they procured their targets. They were selling their killing power for monetary gain, which I took major issue with, as it in my view results only in indiscriminate/senseless and widespread murder. Ledah had very little to do with the plan if I did tell him about it, actually it was one or two other non caretaker players who I mostly decided to confer with about it, before ultimately requesting Phantasm for a use of his kill tool which he obliged.Claim 2: My idea was we could transfer the Caretakers into being a Necrovion alliance under her claim to the throne which I have even since the disbanding of Necrovion seen as legitimate, much like how I still see the Caretakers as a legitimate alliance through its own untimely and perhaps just as preposterous disbanding. In doing so we could have opened up the land again, though proven not to be required. I didn't speak much more about this idea than I did in that quote. I would not have been doing that because I want to be a part of necrovion, I much prefer the east or even MDA, but because of the connection the Caretakers has to death which I have seen Necrovion represent more aspects of, including housing the land of the dead within it. Also due to my preference to be altruistic, specially to my friends."Caretakers have a love for the end of things. Sometimes the end of things do not come as fast as they would like, so they….hasten things."Going to reiterate this quote because it has always stuck with me and one of the main reasons I joined the Caretakers, but I see it not so much as we need to cause the end, but that the end is something we fixate on. I was not too long before joining the Caretakers a mortuary driver's assistant, I have brought dead people from their homes and hospitals to the morgue. Reviving the dead is not something I am capable of. This is to say that my idea of what the Caretakers are has never been about life or rebirth or some sort of revival.Caretakers would be something more like a caregiver for those who are alive and a caretaker for that which isn't. The distinction is that we provide support to people, and provide continuity to everything else. So the "mostly true" part wasn't sarcasm, I do think we shouldn't be going around killing people, causing death, but to preserve it where possible. When it's not possible, we ensure that the status quo, if you will, remains in balance.Yes my activity has been lacking this year, but this whole year essentially has been less than ideal for me, I didn't have a phone for a period and am currently homeless in a shelter, among some other stuff, so I have much less time to do things this year. So I have to apologize to Mur and Chewett who I have obligations for and anyone else who might've been hoping to see me around.But overall I see removing an alliance as similar to removing roles or tools from people, that it should be done sparingly with good reason, not just because they are inactive, as often it will just rob the realm of what could have been had they still had the chance to do what they wanted. So I will say now that this is a good chance for us Caretakers to do what we want now instead of doing what we were "meant" to do. Edited November 8Nov 8 by Mallos Report
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.