[quote name='Kafuuka' post='32527' date='Jun 1 2009, 05:57 PM']Alts: it takes a lot of work to make an original character and write a background story. This is true even more if you are an adept writer because you will never be satisfied with your work. "For every sentence I kept, I have thrown away at least one page of writing." (don't remember which writer said that)
No matter how good you think you are, there are no guarantees to win and there aren't any retries either. And there is a chance people will notice your style. The only reason people will try it against all odds, would be that they have too many active days to participate and too much time. I'd propose a side contest with a smaller reward, for older players/alts... but it'd be silly to have good character designs go to waste after the contest is over.[/quote]
If i am going to speak for myself then i would most definately make an alt and Rp him. This would be mainly for the reward. But because i rarely Rp as Chewett and none of you have found out some of my better alts (no not Chewett the Noob) then i would say i would be able to give a good go at this competition
[quote name='Kafuuka' post='32527' date='Jun 1 2009, 05:57 PM']I also suggest having the candidates sign up for this and have them idle in a designated place, especially if you use a small amount of judges. Timezones make it hard to read everybody's papers.[/quote]
Perhaps they could not blank their personal page? Then they would be able to see it on their profile?
[quote name='Watcher' post='32528' date='Jun 1 2009, 06:04 PM'][i]Hold the contest every six to eight weeks.[/i]
This may mean lowering the awarded sums or changing the award itself. However, this would give new people incentive to become creative and work toward integrating themselves into the world in which we play.[/quote]
Would it become too devauled if it was this often? Then many people would get an award. How long can this go on for? It would give me much more chance to win or place.
[quote name='Watcher' post='32528' date='Jun 1 2009, 06:04 PM'][i]Established characters as judges who are not RPCs.[/i]
There are many who are very active in this world, who are well known, and who play their characters exceedingly well. These are the people who you would want to judge the stories and papers of others. I would suggest staying away from those who have been established as RPCs only because they have other duties to which they are to be devoting their time.
Characters such as Keith Moon, Awiiya, Innocence, Willem Redbeard, and Firsanthalas are the some of the best. These would be the kinds of people to approach to judge others.[/quote]
Im sure (and i only speak of my knowing some rpcs) that some of them would like to judge a contest like this. Some of the best role players are rpcs. But not all of the rpcs are good roleplayers *cough* me *cough*
[quote name='Watcher' post='32528' date='Jun 1 2009, 06:04 PM'][i]Public displays.[/i]
Those who have been nominated for this contest should have portions, if not all, of their papers viewable by the public. This could be having everything displayed on their personal page or opening a topic on the forum that would allow them to post something about themselves along with selected sections of their papers. A limit would be called for, however, as you would not want all contestants to use 50,000 or more characters. In this case, a forum post should be short and simple.
Paper length, of course, would be up to the discretion of the individual.[/quote]
Again i say that all their papers should be on public displey on their public page. It would be so much easier to get rid of the problem of timezones.
[quote name='Watcher' post='32528' date='Jun 1 2009, 06:04 PM'][i]Multiple criteria for judging.[/i]
As you have already noted, there should be several categories to aid in the selection of a winner. Consider participation in the world as one. This might discourage alternate accounts, though nothing is certain. If one has to be active in the world to be considered for this award, it would reduce the likelihood of someone creating an interesting story and then sitting around in a sanctuary, hoping to get noticed.
Otherwise, you have already mentioned several other criteria which should be evaluated.[/quote]
It wouldnt discourage a person who wants the reward really. only some of the people who would like it. Have you even seen Chewett in game? Really? I dont really play Chewett as i prefere obscurity. Its intresting to see how people treat a nobody.
BTW: if you are trying to work out my alts i use proxies. Most of them are from the US but at least one is from romania