Chewett

Feedback available here:

After the fishing competition we sat and discussed it: Great to see so many people here. Some notes: Immortalising Great Fish Some discussion was had about having some way to immortalise "The biggest" fish you caught Skin a fish and store it somewhere mounted? Storm Lightning killing people People were generally in favour of this New accounts creating storms was removed during competition due to alt abuse Lots of spells were used removing storms due to the concern/risk Only Samon died in the end! Fishing gear No one found it apart from Ledah and Chewett (who had a lot of comments about it from Mur on text) Maybe it needs to be more obviously there when you don't have the right tag? You should be able to "return" gear to shared item locations Generally people were confused about it, couldn't find it, didn't know it existed Fish Market Some players commented it is complex but they will learn People like the AP gain from the fish More Junk - Some people would like to see more Junk Historical competition results People would like to see all competitions and their results somewhere Maybe in the fish market Maybe in the archives with the other logs Sushi - Nep would like sushi as an available option for food Pet Food - Fish should be created to be fed to pets Weather Some people would like Weather to NOT be cancellable so you can't change the weather with a spell Some would like weather to stack, So if you cast a spell it will apply once the current weather finishes Some would like competitions with fixed with and a "forcast" of when it will be what weather Fishing Medal - The winner of a fishing contest should get a medal, If you win twice you get a gold medal and are excluded from winning future contests like Heads Contest (You can win, you just won't get a medal / reward and others will) Different Catching Minigames - Some would like to see extra minigames Crabs and Eels - Ledah would like crabs, Lobsters, and other crustations. Marvolo would like to see Eels Length of the competition People felt that 48 hours was quite long Some people suggested making it only 2 hours, but you could "pick" your 2 hours at any time during the competition Different types of competition - Some suggested different types of competition, e.g. biggest 5 fish caught Banning all spells / Killing - Some suggested banning all spells and killing during the competition to "force" fairness CC @Sephirah Caelum @Muratus del Mur @Else @Invie @Ledah @Miq @Nep @Marvolo @Syrian @redneck @Seigheart @Vahr @Blackshade Rider

I have a kill item coming off cooldown, it's making me itchy.

Auction solves that IMO. Any trading people do can let them grow their gold and silver.

I don't like the idea of someone being able to put large quantities of points into a specific thing, e.g. buying large quantities of gold. I like how it doesn't necessarily encourage whaling by giving a selection. I already have a concern that forge is Pay-To-Win where those who have lots of cash can just keep making OP items.

My suggestion would be to ask the caretakers? It's their tool, they can choose what they do with it.

As there is interest in adding more generic images, I have suggested a new feature: https://forum.magicduel.com/topic/29261-new-way-to-suggest-generic-item-images/

We have a lot of generic items that I am keen to add images for, but there is no way to add the generic images.# New way to suggest generic images Add a similar interface that allows either uploads, or AI generated images for generic items For generic images, all must be reviewed + approved before applied to all generic items New Feature - Multiple images for generic items It would make generic items a bit more interesting since they could have different images Allow "multiple" generic options for each item Show the different options based on itemId MOD number of generic items (mod being modulus) New Admin Interface List all the current "generic" images stored in the database/filesystem Allow adding them / removing them / etc Make this another part/role of the item approval role

Proposed image, based on the Top spender ticket

Adding searching to the friends list would be useful, Ctrl-F is a bit rubbish for the friends list

This is super outdated, I wouldn't recommend linking to it anymore.

Ewwwww

Only once

I will permit once mistake myself. It only gathered one. If the others who agreed, disagree with my statement, I will prepare some spells

@Ledah

I would extend it if that brings in more friends to help curse

strongcurse, lock in chaos, and everything I have shall be used to protect AWIIYA!

Eggy said they were.

Is this still happening?

This has been resolved.

This has been resolved.

This has been resolved.

Unless we find someone who will purposely lose for us (Hey Mallos, Mr negative 10000 stats) I'm not sure it's going to tend much in the upward direction. I haven't been able to find many people that want to play and the latest tournament got cancelled. Just because of the random chance in many of the games, it's going to be hard, and who wants to play someone good (whose score is tending up) if your score just gets reduced. I'm happy to leave it as it is, but I don't think anyone is going to push for the achievement given the difficultly as it stands.

Being able to create rituals from a creature group would be super useful.

The "Casual gamer" score only increases when you win, and decreases when you lose. Essentially this means that even if you win "most" it's going to take a while to get any points at all. Ledah and I played two games, won and lost one each, and ended up with the same total. This means that "Reach a casual gamer score of 2800. A record that took years of tables, and the realm knows the name." is likely to never happen. I would suggest that instead of it being an absolute ranking, you gain 1 for losing, 2 for winning. Then each game does increase your score a little. Even with that, scoring 2800 will take a LONG time.