Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

MagicDuel Community

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Fishing Competition Feedback

Featured Replies

  • Root Admin

After the fishing competition we sat and discussed it:

Screenshot 2026-11-01 204552.png

Great to see so many people here. Some notes:

  • Immortalising Great Fish

    • Some discussion was had about having some way to immortalise "The biggest" fish you caught

    • Skin a fish and store it somewhere mounted?

  • Storm Lightning killing people

    • People were generally in favour of this

    • New accounts creating storms was removed during competition due to alt abuse

    • Lots of spells were used removing storms due to the concern/risk

    • Only Samon died in the end!

  • Fishing gear

    • No one found it apart from Ledah and Chewett (who had a lot of comments about it from Mur on text)

    • Maybe it needs to be more obviously there when you don't have the right tag?

    • You should be able to "return" gear to shared item locations

    • Generally people were confused about it, couldn't find it, didn't know it existed

  • Fish Market

    • Some players commented it is complex but they will learn

    • People like the AP gain from the fish

  • More Junk - Some people would like to see more Junk

  • Historical competition results

    • People would like to see all competitions and their results somewhere

    • Maybe in the fish market

    • Maybe in the archives with the other logs

  • Sushi - Nep would like sushi as an available option for food

  • Pet Food - Fish should be created to be fed to pets

  • Weather

    • Some people would like Weather to NOT be cancellable so you can't change the weather with a spell

    • Some would like weather to stack, So if you cast a spell it will apply once the current weather finishes

    • Some would like competitions with fixed with and a "forcast" of when it will be what weather

  • Fishing Medal - The winner of a fishing contest should get a medal, If you win twice you get a gold medal and are excluded from winning future contests like Heads Contest (You can win, you just won't get a medal / reward and others will)

  • Different Catching Minigames - Some would like to see extra minigames

  • Crabs and Eels - Ledah would like crabs, Lobsters, and other crustations. Marvolo would like to see Eels

  • Length of the competition

    • People felt that 48 hours was quite long

    • Some people suggested making it only 2 hours, but you could "pick" your 2 hours at any time during the competition

  • Different types of competition - Some suggested different types of competition, e.g. biggest 5 fish caught

  • Banning all spells / Killing - Some suggested banning all spells and killing during the competition to "force" fairness

CC @Sephirah Caelum @Muratus del Mur @Else @Invie @Ledah @Miq @Nep @Marvolo @Syrian @redneck @Seigheart @Vahr @Blackshade Rider

You never asked to come in, Ledah. I maintain that area meticulously. Still working on a bait and tackle shop, and more gardening materials. But since after this, since there are LESS fish..... I'll go ahead and open it up. Feel free to come in...

You might very well enjoy what you might catch!

  • Root Admin

Immortalising Great Fish
- remains todo, its a bit more complicated than this, there are already forge items that can be used for this purpose, i am not sure is good to create a public item for something others tried so hard to create.

Fishing gear

its fine "hidden" as it is, only true fishers will discover it unavoidable, its written in the tag and in info, you where just hasty and number hungry. You can fish just fine without it, but you would get unly to about half, if you like this activity and want to complete a lake for an achievement and such, you will search for ways, and ways are there.

Some people would like to see more Junk
not all junk was discovered yet, so no need for more new ones, this is not a flavor item shop.

People would like to see all competitions and their results

YES, must have, but we deal with it on the next competition

Sushi
- will do

Pet food
- 0 will do, dna changers as for snakes and such


weather
i agree to the change, but its a change that will affect ALL weather. I will probably make weather stack, so weather forecast can be shown and made, but we need a meteorologist or so, maybe shared tools to tell weather, so a person can get them and document them publicly every week. New weather spells would cast weather only later on in the stack, but you will know when "your" weather kicks in.


Fishing Medal
agree

Different Catching Minigames
the possiblity is there, but i am out of ideeas, something to make sense to fishing , not tetris.


Length
this is not for those people then

Different types of competition
yes, will happen, when you want the next one? :D

Banning all spells / Killing
Absolutely...not. Anything you can do, spells, tricks, anything, is allowed under same rules it is allowed in general in the game. Alt abuse is still alt abuse, dont do it, using items just because you have them is ok as always, except for some special items.

its already a lot on my list, so i will probably not consider later things unless they are really good. Also i will probably not make all on this list but just some...some are really good.

so it is okay to lock someone in chaos for a few hours or kill them and needing 3 days for the marigold, but casting a weather spell is frowned upon?

it is just another spell you obtained to use freely imo.

just like you said earlier:

17 hours ago, Muratus del Mur said:

Anything you can do, spells, tricks, anything, is allowed under same rules it is allowed in general in the game.

  • Root Admin

Has nothing to do with your personal comfort during the competition. I implemented the weather changes not because it was disturbing your fishing, but because I think in general this way of having weather is far more interesting than having it just as a spell with immediate effects.

4 hours ago, Muratus del Mur said:

Has nothing to do with your personal comfort during the competition. I implemented the weather changes not because it was disturbing your fishing, but because I think in general this way of having weather is far more interesting than having it just as a spell with immediate effects.

Maybe more advanced weather manipulators(like marvolo) could get that ability to manipulate weather immediately

Weather tags could be a side tree from the fishing tags, although that means players would need to make a trade off between free access to the highest tier fishing gear or improved weather spells.

Regardless I would be in favor of having higher level weather spells cause their effect immediately rather than delayed. This would also allow weather to be summoned at specific moments for dramatic effect.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 17.7k
  • Total Posts 183.8k

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.