Ivorak
-
Joined
-
Last visited
Posts posted by Ivorak
-
-
9 hours ago, Chewett said: Does "Read later" top right of the panel not do what you want?
Sometimes, but ability to schedule that would be nicer. This one is probably less important than the other two for me.
Another one that's been bothering me for awhile:
I often see announcements first through the Discord channel, but when I click on them to expand them I'm usually on mobile and the logged out layout for new announcements cuts off a good portion of the message making them really hard to read. A responsive layout would be a big plus there in particular! -
Good thread! (Reminds me of https://blog.sbensu.com/posts/friction-logs/, one of which I've been meaning to write up for MD for a while now)
A few quality of life requests of my own around the in-game inbox:Threaded messages - would help me keep track of a conversation history better, and especially relevant to reducing clutter now that the auction house sends messages for every time I get outbid on an item.
Starred messages - let me star or bookmark the most important messages I get
Snoozed messages - let me snooze a message to a point in the future when it'll appear as a new unread message again. This would help me manage responses based on time I actually have available or more generally when the "stars align" and I can actually take action on a request.
-
Edited by Ivorak
Oops, sorry for the duplicate info, I had an out of date thread loaded7 hours ago, Chewett said: Sorry I don't know what you mean. I'm not aware of tools that do/don't deplete?
I think they might be new. The herb basket I got from the evo store has this feature (and I just confirmed by harvesting from a location with less 0.5 resources and it remained at 0.5 resources).
-
-
How will you handle tools that don't deplete? E.g. "A plain little basket, worn smooth by long use, for gathering herbs without stripping the ground bare. It still turns up a sprig where a patch has grown thin, though it teaches no herbalism and leaves no faster trace than a patient hand." Use of these tools still leaves chat traces.
-
I've been testing out the pool table minigame and there are some (minor in the scheme of things) issues that affect playability.
- You can't drag beyond the table boundaries for shot strength (this one might be intentional to make things harder?)
- Unclear what the reward criteria are (is it one silver coin each after 5/10/50 wins count?)
- Angle/strength indicator keeps glitching out
- If you accidentally click outside the modal it dismisses the game (there are many modals in MD where this should be the expected behavior and isn't. And here it's the opposite)
- I think it lets you resume a game, but it either told me I was the wrong set (stripes vs. solids) or it added back different balls, or something else that made it confusing so I was aiming at the wrong thing. -
-
-
-
-
-
I like this proposal. It solves the problems of 1) the same votes always going to the same players, and 2) having to decide which player to "dislike" when there are no active players in the list who I actually dislike (I usually end up choosing at random amongst the player names I don't know well, which I'd prefer not to be forced to do, especially since sometimes those might be newer players).
I would also like to bring attention to the karmic cantrips proposal I wrote up at https://miscellaneum.wordpress.com/2023/03/19/popular-≠-interesting/ (section at the end, quoted below). Could be a standalone alternative, or the cantrips (and the reasons given) could be included along the player names as context. This could help with creating a more timely reputation system as well (e.g., I could vote based on the ratio of blessings to hexes a player has received in the past month, and whether or not I agree with the reasons given, rather than a long held grudge or rather I think they picked a cool name at the time of account creation, etc.)
QuoteKarmic spell system – Each active player gets 3 blessings and 3 hexes a week that they can cast on other players. Maybe they also need to specify a category and write a short reason as to why they’re casting each blessing/hex. These blessings/hexes need not do anything at the time they are cast, besides entering the reason for the use of this cantrip in a log for later perusal in the Log Review Room. Main differences between this and current system, is that each karmic cantrip is a reaction to a particular action and that caster shares a note on why they’re blessing/cursing the other player.
For example:
:Ivorak blesses Nonavar for his guidance of a fresh arrival from Gateway Island:Ivorak curses Ravanon for their poor trading etiquette and foul mouth
-
On 12/19/2023 at 4:39 PM, Muratus del Mur said:
By purchasing a cat, you agree that you will accept any future behavior of this animal, including running away from you, mating with other cats and created unwanted kitties, or even if it starts to eat your food. It currently does not do so, but like i said i have plans for this one.
Methinks if a cat is so valuable, kitties would be desired as well. This is a male cat though, and I assume that ownership of kittens would go to the owner of the mother cat under common law?
-
55 minutes ago, Aia del Mana said:
Of wishpoints: I am not opposed to a single wishpoint (or fewer - e.g. one per every two players) being granted given the paucity of them presently.
I'm not so fond of the idea of giving out wishpoints for Christmas, I feel like wishpoints should remain in the domain of special reward for quests and special effortful actions. (Though I will note there is the precedent of wishpoints for cumulative and consecutive active days.)
If wishpoints are given out, I don't think it should be random. Make it for all players who show up for Christmas (and perhaps meet other requirements, be it active days, MP level, or some other measure of past and present activity), but please don't make wishpoints a lottery.
Other than that I like all of the suggestions above. -
I think it would make sense to remove the locate spell from the wish shop going forward, at least until the two evolve to be more different as Mur hinted at.
Us vets probably don't need a refund, but if I was a newbie spending my first wishpoint and hadn't learned about /seen yet, I think I would be a bit annoyed. -
-
Some assorted observations/thoughts:
- Once upon a time it was considered the case that MP6 Protectors had "life and death power" over their worshippers. I think we should make concrete these life and death powers, and also make it clear that worshipping a Protector has tradeoffs.
- Some players are using their Protector abilities for general aid to newbies.
- I think this (#2) should likely be a separate function, and Protectors should more "factional", e.g., a group of players aligned on a mission should raise up their own Protector and that Protector should serve their faction before all others.
- If #3, then I think it likely makes sense to restrict Protector spells to these Protectors (no spell stones).
- If #4, then I think it also makes sense to give Protectors more powerful spells.
- If #5, then we should also have ways for opposing factions to hurt/disable Protectors.
-
Not a meme, but for the lighthouse enthusiasts among us: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/lighthouses-give-away-free-180982261/
-
On 5/3/2023 at 11:59 AM, Fyrd Argentus said:
RESULTS:
Nobody got the wp for a story submission, as there were NONE!
Invie gets the wp for best score - 4 opponents vanquished.
Chewett, Chriselnenepr, Ivorak, and Syrian with 3 each get a prize from the list below in order of their responses.
Ledah with 2 points gets to choose after the others, or after 1 month if they fail to choose.
Prize choices include:
Gold Avatar Token
3 Gold Coins
Spell Stone from my inventory
Jewelry or Gem item from my inventory (excepting quest items: Reverse Pocket Watch, Mood Ring, or Empty Locket)
Creature: Imp, Pimp,BP Archer, Colored Tree, Joker, 17th Elu, or WWild Egg >100 days age and 1000 bird shards.I'll take the 3 gold coins
-
Additional feedback and ideas (cross-post from https://miscellaneum.wordpress.com/2023/03/19/popular-≠-interesting/😞
QuoteA little over a year ago, a fairly unpopular feature was added, that many players have referred to as some variation of “the popularity contest”:
QuoteNew way of rating
On every 3rd day, after the 3rd hour, people with more than 3 consecutive active days, will get to vote who they sympathize and who they dislike from the recently active people. This is a dynamic rating, and will count long term but also short term. With this thing i will be able to draw involvement trends, see who is more appreciated by the community and who not. Your entire activity will be rated by the community in this way. Obviously your votes will remain secret, so you can be totally honest with your choice and not fear upsetting someone you downvoted.It might be a controversial feature, because very interesting characters can very well be less popular, or even hated, but the thing is, there is always someone more dull, that you can downvote, than someone interesting but less known, or villain kind.
Depending on how this goes, my plans are to use these ratings, combined with active days, and wp points total, to decide who gets access to A25 tools, or other key roles.
Only very interesting people should get hold of god-like power tools in md, to shape the realm, and a part of this difficult decision is now in your power.
https://magicduel.com/page/Announcement/view/5512
Some were upset with the notion of ranking (or being ranked by) other players. Others simply found the interstitial screen on log in disruptive and annoying. Personally, I’m not upset with the notion of a reputational system nor the interstitial screen on log in (especially now that the frequency seems to have been reduced), but I’m confused by the feature launch announcement. Are we voting on how much we like/dislike someone or how interesting they are?
I struggle to see how one can be used as a proxy for the other, and I also am concerned that if I dislike someone too frequently, that it’s an implied vote for their interestingness and that they may receive some of these “god-like power tools” alluded to in the announcement. Often my dislike for a player stems from their lack of responsibility or common sense behavior, rather than a in-character grudge.
In the spirit of constructive criticism, here’s a few other ways to get a sense of a player’s interestingness:
- Nominations – An ongoing quest where any player can nominate another player, with a short writeup of why they think they’re interesting. Keep the accepted nominations secret and let them accumulate over time until there’s enough cause for a reward to the nominated player. Perhaps a gold coin to the person nominating, for every accepted nomination, or keep whether a nomination has been accepted/rejected secret as well, and have a more substantial “finder’s fee” for each nominator once the nominee is selected for a reward.
-
Called shots – It could be interesting to track what a player sets out to accomplish (ambition) and what they achieve (follow through). A good way to do this is to have a place for a player to record “called shots”, goals that are recorded in advance of tackling them. Two possible ways to implement this are:
- Called shots are obscured/encrypted in a new log and (at a later date) marked as completed by the player. This way we could measure the duration from idea to implementation (longer time indicates long term planning / forethought).
- Alternatively the player selects an unveil time when entering the goal, e.g., “I will achieve this within X days/months”, and “I was successful/unsuccessful” upon reveal (with less time indicating ability to follow through on plans quickly, assuming goal was sufficiently ambitious).
- Personal Change Log – Similar to called shots, but simpler. Players don’t have to pre-commit to a path of action, but are simply encouraged to write up their accomplishments every quarter or year or so.
Returning, for a moment, to reputation systems, I think that could be done better than forced voting on an interval as well. Here are some ideas there:
- Karmic spell system – Each active player gets 3 blessings and 3 hexes a week that they can cast on other players. Maybe they also need to specify a category and write a short reason as to why they’re casting each blessing/hex. These blessings/hexes need not do anything at the time they are cast, besides entering the reason for the use of this cantrip in a log for later perusal in the Log Review Room. Main differences between this and current system, is that each karmic cantrip is a reaction to a particular action and that caster shares a note on why they’re blessing/cursing the other player.
-
-
Edited by Ivorak
This is great; I'm super excited for this!
Before I start making suggestions had a couple questions for clarification:
- If one can only follow a single branch and completing a path unlocks great powers, then does the depth of that branch matter in regards to what the reward for that path is? For example, in one of your diagrams above "carto 2" is a depth of 5 whereas "asd resss" is a depth of 2; do they both unlock a similarly valuable reward? Or does "asd resss" unlock a lesser reward than the longer path? Or perhaps "asd resss" unlocks a similarly valuable reward but is harder to unlock to compensate for the lesser number of steps?
- Also, does being able to complete only a single path mean that certain abilities are locked off from a player forever, since they won't be able to complete the other paths?
- Regarding the "What I need" request, do you want suggestions for a complete tree structure and all the requisite parts for implementation (i.e., tag names, images, tag structure, and tag dispatcher locations)? Or is it helpful to make suggestions for an incomplete tag dispatcher structure? Or even everything but drawings, if I'm not much of an artist or don't have drawing supplies on hand at the moment?
-
24 minutes ago, jakubhi said:
PLEASE, do not forget to somehow point out the decorations you found inside the screenshots, this can be done with some red circles/arrows or just a simple text notes under the screenshot.
Oops.. I was taking screenshots of the decorations per the initial instructions, but this makes me think I should have been taking screenshots of the entire scene and annotating them?
-
Frequent DNS errors
in Bug Report
This is still happening. And cost me my consecutive active days streak the other day.
I tried debugging a few weeks ago. It seems the name servers are flakier than they should be and the low TTL means nothing gets cached day to day. Couldn't figure out more than that though.