I will be honest, I have not read all of the responses in this thread because seriously, some of them I am incredibly disappointed with. A few of these replies make me want to ask: "Does anyone even remember that we are to make our own fun in this game? Does anyone even know how to have fun anymore?"
No the quest was not perfectly constructed to a T, spitshined and covered in protective wax.
No quest in the game of MagicDuel ever will be.
The point is that this was a decent attempt to actually do something creative and entertaining in the game for people who are more than obviously bored with how things have been progressing. It was by far, in my opinion, the most entertaining thing to occur in game in a long, long while.
I appreciate the work that was put into constructing the plot arc, not everyone was happy with some of the things that occurred and not everyone was able to be involved, but for those who were able to be involved seemed to be enjoying themselves with it. Really, is a game not about having fun? Did we forget that?
Just remember, Keith did not have to write an entertaining quest for any of you, he did not have to give rewards for your enjoyment either. The fact is that he did, and any number of people could have been involved if they had truly wanted to be.
[i]Edited for clarity.[/i]