It is an interesting idea. It could work but it would need to work alongside other roles since there is not enough people in jail. To those that worry about people being subjective. Everyone is subjective, some people can remove themselves from the equation and make them appear fair. However generally this means they are unfair to themselves but this is generally tolerated. It doesnt matter that there is no one who is absolutely fair becuase thats impossible. In short, ignore those who tell you the role is pointless as you cant find a fair person, they are being naive, we have given many more important and powerful rules to those who are considered biased. And please people, dont just shoot down an idea becuase you dont "get" it, its rather rude. I spent a decent amount of time coding a whole new "punishment" interface for PoE for her dream role which includes punishment such as stat damage, temporary bad effects and similar. Repurposing a similar item could be interesting to see. I like the idea, sounds pretty cool.