Chewett

Then it looks like we are all agreed and this is now the rule.

Thats a bug, its on my list of things todo but I havent had time yet. MD doesnt have a nice way to make pages not require login atm while keeping all the core functions.

Please do not publish things to google docs, they are a horrific format for information retrieval. This is why we need a discussion about format, because google docs are horrendous to find information with. Especially if everyone is going to have their own doc. This needs to be planned properly.

I removed this doubting you will listen. so I cant show you exactly what I said. But the jist of it was, there is a lot harder work being done regularly by a lot more people than this. The hardest part is probably actually setting the system up as it takes ages as its rubbish and I do that.

I know what you have done, and what you are doing, and still disagree that you are the right person to do it, you havent grown up yet. Dont assume everyone who knows is happy with you. A lot more people know than you think. Also calling out "Oh I would love to tell you but I cant" is bragging. You can say it nicely without overstressing it multiple times of "Oh I cant, sorry"

No one doesnt like pagination since he will have to do more work with his scripts. Paginate it, Works for normal people really well.

No min, No max. You were the one raising the issues, no one else I think.

So you wont be using the duplicate nominations to remove categories with large amount of people?

send it to coder@magicduel.com with the full version for me to review please.

If you are told to keep something secret, you should, the translators didnt. I have been trying to have a discussion RE spoilers for a while. Personally I think we need to properly document the combat so people can actually learn things and work with it, instead of keeping it all spoilery. Because Iv worked with you and know you. You are not good at planning.

Im not involved with this until some things are cleared up, Mur you have an email. It needs to be organised, properly, and we need a decent standard and not everyone using different things. Also, I dont trust many people in the game not to share it. People are too friendly and dont have self respect. See: the translation people, nearly every single one of them SOLD the story mode texts. E.g. Did you know you, as a normal player, can taint angiens. No one has yet found that spoiler and since I dont share secrets no one has done it. I point out this, because for a time you used the forum (hidden section) and then Kyphis has been (unsure if he still does) made google docs (which are horrific) and its all disjointed and useless.

Make it paginate and auto scroll through the pages. Simple, Mur do it!

Wont the trading reset it?

no you dont get a say, shush you. VOTE AILITH!

Ailith should be allowed to win categories. Because there is no way she can change the results. VOTE AILITH! DOWN WITH GRIDO! VOTE JOHN SMITH! EDIT: Solution for min/max problem If there is only one person in a category, I nominate JOHN SMITH. ok?

Grido Disagrees.

John Smith for them then. Someone nominate Ailith and Eon plz, thanks.

Adventuring Award - dst Champion Fighter - Eon Helper of the Year - EE Most Popular - Ailith Outstanding Service to MD - dst

I would have said thats part of the organisers duty...

No we dont ban for it, But we do reverse the bid and sometimes take part of the coin for the treasury. Depends on who does it, if they should have known better, etc. Please send me a message.

It was announced... Multiple times.

If Mur isnt going to do anything I will eventually get around to making it look better when im back. Tis my job.

The system as I designed it never forgets anything. However I have on many occasions de-alted people. Iv no clue how Mur will handle it since I emailed him telling him that he needs to deal with this when I am away. Normally council would but...

I have rewritten it above. Compare grido's version with mine.

- There will be a maximum of 10 categories. Do not specify how many cateogories. - There will be a minimum of 3 and a maximum of 5 players nominated for each category. Previous years you have arbitarily decided who is in and out. This is entirely unfair. I raised concern on this previously and you were flippant. I do not feel this is the correct response. Please give a public answer one way or another. - Past winners will be allowed to be nominated again, however, if there are more than 5 names nominated when it closes, those will be the first removed. Unfair. Remove this. If they are the best they should be in with everybody else. You are trying to give more people a chance to make it "nice". - Mur cannot be nominated (sorry Mur), and Chewett cannot be nominated for Top Techy (or another award along the same lines). Remove my name and that restriction. I havent made MDscript this year so could not be nominated anyway. If I did make some I would like to be able to get it. - Previous Fossil (or a similar award if that does not exist this year) winners, cannot win again. Why? There is absoluely no reason to have this restriction other to be "fair" again. Make it so that the best fossil can get the award. Simple as that. - There will be no restriction on the amount of voters, there will however be a limited timeframe to vote in - this will be 11 days. 11 is arbitary, make it two weeks to be entirely fair. As thats two full work weeks and two full weekends. - If you vote for yourself in anything, all your votes will be discounted. When was this ever a rule? Why? Whats the point?