Root Admin Muratus del Mur Posted April 29, 2016 Root Admin Report Share Posted April 29, 2016 (edited) This is weird, but i am opening a trial myself about a decision i am about to take also myself, against Aethon. I feel i might be way to stressed and angry right now, and because aethon took the time to reply actively to all acuses i brought him, i felt its needed he gets a chance for a public opinion that might save him or punish him. I will try to keep it short. I need a vote to undestand how YOU all and each see this situation, also because its not the first time i am either to lenient or to harsh to abuses...so...here is your occasion to be the jury. FIRST I work with Aethon on the crit combiner, i am happy about his overall progress with the resources documentation, we both put a lot of effort in doing that...so at some point i give him two powerful items to help him conduct his task better. I give him Death Patrol pass papers, offering him immunity from being killed in Necrovion, and Fruitjuice, offering him basically UNLIMITED action points. I tell him not to abuse those. what happens next will be divided in two, what he sias and what i say, both true MY VERSION i tell him not to abuse the ap item, but if he wants something he sees around he can make a list. My intention was to reward him things he wanted while being able to view all necrovions treasures. I told him clearly that the items are for doing his research project, for nothign else. Its kind of obvious anyway. INSTEAD, first thing he does is he goes the next day or so, and grabs the rare crits everybody wants in necrovion, and explores the secret tunnel that is publicly closed so it had absolutely no connection with his resource research. He appologised about it, blaming it on a missunderstanding or betterw aid on the fact that it reads from the chat that i meant something different. My argument is that its kind of damn obvious that if you get an admin tool of such power you dont make consuses or interpret words, you are supposed to kind of know by common sense what is abuse and what not....or...not? HIS VERSION He understands he can grab whatever he wants but keep a list of all that for later. He sais he was in the crits recruiting place before, on his own, anyway. Also, sais he didnt took the crits to sell them so its not about abuse. A fragment of chat between us is controversial, he presents it in his defence so i will post it here as well. He claims i said "excelent" to the last part about grabbing, i claim i said "excelent" to the row above with "doublecheck if uncertain" part. He blames it on the missunderstnading and appologised about it. LOG Quote [26/04/16 05:44] Muratus del Mur:you will need free passage into necrovion, while you work on this [26/04/16 05:44] Muratus del Mur:for this you will get two items [26/04/16 05:45] Muratus del Mur:one will be usable for ewntire md, it will give you LOTs of ap [26/04/16 05:45] Muratus del Mur:and the other one will be used to survive the death patrol [26/04/16 05:45] Muratus del Mur:both are just during this project [26/04/16 05:45] Aethon:Okie dokie [26/04/16 05:46] Muratus del Mur:and with the mention that if you tap into the treasures of necrovion, you will do so just for research purposes, not for contraband.selling, not even personal collection. [26/04/16 05:46] Muratus del Mur:but you can make a list of things you find and wish to keep, in the end if you do good i might leve you to keep them [26/04/16 05:46] Aethon:Of course [26/04/16 05:46] Muratus del Mur:just dont take big stocks [26/04/16 05:46] Aethon:And thank you [26/04/16 05:46] Muratus del Mur:like the crits hidden here [26/04/16 05:46] Aethon:I shan't [26/04/16 05:47] Muratus del Mur:please don't ruin this cooperation by stepping wrong [26/04/16 05:47] Aethon:I won't, if I'm unsure I'll double check with you first. [26/04/16 05:47] Aethon:Anything I grab, I'll keep a list of so you know at the end. [26/04/16 05:47] Muratus del Mur:exactly CONCLUSIONS state your opinion and if he is punishable, and in what way if he is. Lets see if there is a general opinion. Is he punishable or not, WHAT punishment for this or what to do if anything. This will create a precendent too. I am not makign this thread public because i dont know what i would do , but because i am concerned that what i will do will be unapprorpiate or unbalanced THE VOTING WILL DECIDE - PLEASE VOTE AFTER JUDGING WELL. IF YOU COMMENT BUT DONT VOTE, YOUR COMMENT ITS USELESS I will vote last, i don't wish to see the results while i read your comments, because except this particular incident, this "trial" will help me understand what to do on my own in future situations. WIll i give priority to the wording or to my intentions that might be confusing? You vote this case well and wise, IT IS NOT A POPULARITY CONTEST Edited April 29, 2016 by Muratus del Mur added the note about the vote being the decisive factor, Its the fairest way Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.