Thursday at 03:20 AM5 days comment_207683 While it may be harassment in a sense, I wouldn't consider it abuse unless your role was specifically geared towards using your tools or available methods to help the dead. Which you say you would help the dead in your topic on it. It is not helping to revive someone that wants to be dead.You can't have it both ways, to say you will help the dead and that reviving players against their will is doing better work than the caretakers, while also saying your role isn't geared towards reviving when neither was the caretakers.If you don't want to flounder I suggest you answer what your role is supposed to be in relation to helping the dead... Report
Thursday at 03:23 AM5 days comment_207684 2 minutes ago, Mallos said:While it may be harassment in a sense, I wouldn't consider it abuse unless your role was specifically geared towards using your tools or available methods to help the dead. Which you say you would help the dead in your topic on it. It is not helping to revive someone that wants to be dead.You can't have it both ways, to say you will help the dead and that reviving players against their will is doing better work than the caretakers, while also saying your role isn't geared towards reviving when neither was the caretakers.If you don't want to flounder I suggest you answer what your role is supposed to be in relation to helping the dead...No offense mallos but I do not have to answer to you Edit: you can see what my role is if you journey to the vigil house Edited Thursday at 03:24 AM5 days by Blackshade Rider Report
Thursday at 02:46 PM5 days comment_207692 I have been following this discussion carefully, and there is something that troubles me.We are speaking so much about death, resurrection, rights, and responsibilities that I wonder whether we are losing sight of what we want the Dead to become.Samon wishes to remain dead, and Blackshade chooses to bring him back to life. The Caretakers have come to an end, yet many of us struggle to accept their dissolution. There is something worth reflecting upon in both situations: we seem much more willing to defend the endings we choose than those imposed upon us.I do not think resurrection is necessarily an act of kindness simply because it restores life. Nor do I think remaining dead is necessarily an act of wisdom simply because it is a choice. Our intentions matter, but so do the consequences of our actions.And perhaps the same applies to the Caretakers. Their dissolution does not erase what they accomplished, just as their history does not necessarily mean they had to continue unchanged.What concerns me most is what happens next. We can spend our time proving who cared more, who was wronged, and who deserves an apology. But what will remain of all this when the arguments are over?I would rather see us create something that gives the living a reason to remember the dead, and the dead a reason to remain part of the realm.Perhaps that is a question worth asking each of ourselves: Are we protecting something we value, or have we become so occupied with defending it that we are preventing it from growing? Report
Thursday at 03:23 PM5 days comment_207693 36 minutes ago, Sephirah Caelum said:I have been following this discussion carefully, and there is something that troubles me.We are speaking so much about death, resurrection, rights, and responsibilities that I wonder whether we are losing sight of what we want the Dead to become.Samon wishes to remain dead, and Blackshade chooses to bring him back to life. The Caretakers have come to an end, yet many of us struggle to accept their dissolution. There is something worth reflecting upon in both situations: we seem much more willing to defend the endings we choose than those imposed upon us.I do not think resurrection is necessarily an act of kindness simply because it restores life. Nor do I think remaining dead is necessarily an act of wisdom simply because it is a choice. Our intentions matter, but so do the consequences of our actions.And perhaps the same applies to the Caretakers. Their dissolution does not erase what they accomplished, just as their history does not necessarily mean they had to continue unchanged.What concerns me most is what happens next. We can spend our time proving who cared more, who was wronged, and who deserves an apology. But what will remain of all this when the arguments are over?I would rather see us create something that gives the living a reason to remember the dead, and the dead a reason to remain part of the realm.Perhaps that is a question worth asking each of ourselves: Are we protecting something we value, or have we become so occupied with defending it that we are preventing it from growing?Well said Report
Friday at 03:09 AM4 days comment_207706 Mallos, I am going to respectfully disagree. Harassment is a pattern of unwanted, offensive, or intimidating behavior directed at an individual or group that causes emotional distress, fear, or harm. In this case, he has something to gain by violating the wishes of Samon. He is refusing to acknowledge the request to (rightfully of their own accord) remain dead. The lack of remaining dead is therefor interfering with his plans to deal with BSR who has, by all means, proven he should receive some sense of accountability for his actions. A bully shouldn't get away with accountability just because we want to get caught up splitting hairs for semantics. Report
Friday at 05:11 AM4 days comment_207707 I didn't say it wasn't harassment, it is. I said it isn't abuse of tools if the tools weren't given for that role or the role isn't tied to using the tools.It's almost like I'm trying to give him an out on this aspect by telling us what his role is supposed to be for then if not reviving players. In my opinion it only looks worse to dodge the question as I can only assume that he would have to make up some lie such as that he's only there to document the dead with his other non revival tool, which could conflict with what the role is supposed to be officially. I do know he has done things on the coding side with Mur surrounding the realm of the dead, but this discussion isn't really about what he has done for the dead land, it is what he is currently doing to the dead people and anyone who seems to take interest in the dead.So does anyone want to see what the vigil house has to do with it?"Are we protecting something we value, or have we become so occupied with defending it that we are preventing it from growing?"I don't want to turn this into Caretaker discussion more than replying to the comments made surrounding it here but like I said in the other topic on CTs I was willing to let the caretakers grow away from something I value (the east, into a Necrovion alliance) as well as grow into something we weren't meant to be about (life, as opposed to death). That being said I protect what I value and end up losing those things anyways, often due to my own fault, so I see the tradeoff you are referencing, and why it's being said here as people will be stubborn to give any ground when they find something they value. I always prefer familiarity over change but it's evident most people are the opposite, change happens anyways, I just wish it could happen in a way that doesn't destroy what people valued to begin with. Edited Friday at 05:26 AM4 days by Mallos Report
Friday at 09:37 AM4 days comment_207708 With regards to BSR, some may say he is lashing out after being bullied. Those people miss who cast the first stone, and kept throwing them despite being given more chances than anyone else ever has.When it comes to him, those people would call his pattern of behaviour an "isolated incident". He is not worth your time, nor your words.It is interesting however, that his actions are allowed, but the factually true PL entries that have been placed on him have been deleted, it seems? The log of what he has done is worse than his actions, clearly!For Sephi, unfortunately if you keep looking the other way, turning another cheek, some people keep pushing. At some point in time, a line has to be drawn, and you have to give someone as good as you got - or walk away.As it stands, whatever people need to turf this sad limpet out of the Graveyard, and to place someone more worthy in the role, I shall provide, as I can. Report
Friday at 12:08 PM4 days comment_207709 @Mallos , I agree that change does not have to destroy what came before it. The Caretakers have come to an end, but their history and contributions remain part of the realm. No decision can take that away.@Ledah , I agree that patience has its limits. Understanding someone does not mean excusing them. But I also believe that accountability and exclusion are not the same thing.We have all made mistakes — some with consequences that extended far beyond ourselves. If we are to be judged only by our worst decisions, how many of us would still have a place in this realm?The Caretakers have been dissolved, and Blackshade has been entrusted with his role. We may disagree with those decisions, but disagreement alone does not undo them.What we can still influence is what happens next. Not by removing people, but by choosing what we build.I am not asking anyone to forget the past or abandon their principles. I am asking whether we can hold people accountable without denying them the possibility of doing something worthwhile in the future. Report
Friday at 01:38 PM4 days comment_207710 Mallos, I agree. And I apologize for my misinterpretation. Thank you for your clarification. Ledah, while it would be great to ignore a fly for laying eggs on flesh, allowance to continue doing so may lead to worse off issues. I recommend looking up fly strike. Regardless, I am finding it odd that logs are disappearing. In fact, I've noticed a very similar thing in a separate area. It's almost as though someone is trying to scrub the misdeeds of those who act atrociously. Report
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.