i am not sure what is unclear from what i said.
let me put it in a different way, maybe it is more clear. Use your logic abilities to combine what i said and figure it out:
NO NO NO cases
- you can't use md art to make money out of it, resell it for CASH, etc. Cash doesn't mean md credits, creatures or other valuables from within md.
- you can't use md art for non md related things, like for your own non-md related project, etc.
- you can't use md art if you do it in such a way that it affects the storyline, theme, or fundamental concepts in md, or if it is causing intentional confusion. To be more clear about this, i care about what you do with the art too, not only if it is for md or not.
- you can't use md art if i say you can't use it... i thought it is obvious.
- you can't use some of the art, those parts that i consider spoilers.
- Things like artwork libraries, collections of images from md, premium creature or rare creature high level artworks, please don't use them.
- you can do walpapers, just avoid confusion and mention they are done by you, with your own efforts. if you plan to put them public anywhere else than md, i don't want people to think they are official artworks, regardless how good or bad they look.
- you can't use it in anything that tends to look official and is not. For example you can't use md artworks in phone games, regardless if they fit the rest of the rules and you give them for free.
YES YES cases
- you can use md artworks to support things related to your md quests, role, research.
- you can use them for personal use, meaning the product of your work wont be shared, given, sold, traded to others. For example if you want to do yourself a mouse pad with the last level of the marksman, fine with me, just don't let me find out .. because if i do it means it is public use and not private.
- you can trade creations based on md artworks as long as they remain within md and the trade is also within md, not for cash, or other non md things. This has also to fit the no spoiling rule.
- you can use it if i said you can use it. obviously.
it is common sense what i ask. Most of the cases of copyright infringement were solved by a simple discussion, and most were involving people not from md. The things i ask about the artworks use are to protect md's values, to keep it unique and keep its quality level. If i would leave the use of the artworks open to anyone and anything, this unicity would fade and "outsiders" as well as new players will no longer know what is md and what is player made.
I can't say BW has the right to blah bla... he is not my business partner, he has no special permission, he is just a player. What i say here is valid for all.
Regarding this particular case, i have nothing against player made walpapers. If you plan to post them on walpaper sites, or post them on your personal site and brag with md artworks to people that have no clue they are not yours, that is NOT ok. To be more sure everything is fine, whoever does such things, please state clearly that artworks is from md, and not done by you, so that new and unaware people know that and to avoid confusion. If you sell it, be sure to specify that you sell the way you combined, altered, mixed it, not the art itself. Like music and remixes, the dj is still an artist, but he is not claiming he composed the music he used for the mix, just the mix itself.
If you do it for profit within md, its fine with me, as long as profit stays within md boundaries. Using md artworks within md , game or community, is the same as using creatures, or surfing the scenes. If you take it outside md, then it is stealing, unless you do everything possible to make it clear they belong to md, and talk to me about it.
One thing that will make me happy every time and is important, make sure whatever you will create using md art has "MagicDuel" or domain name or MagicDuel Adventure written on it. That way it is clear you didnt used the art for other purposes.
I make a huge difference between md people and people outside md. As a player, i will ask you, talk to you, explain you, listen to your reasons and even allow exceptions based on them when it comes to how you can use the artworks. For example, with the walpapers, i could say ok do them, but then ask you to remove one or the other because they don't fit with md or whatever. I expect you to respect that. As a non-player, md outsider, i will not do that. For people that find these artworks sweet and usable for their own projects, i know only to bite and use any tools imaginable to stop them.
If my answer is still not clear ... please put a more clear question.