On 9/1/2026 at 7:09 AM, Chewett said:

If you find these instances please post on the evidence thread.

But I suspect this is not actual depleting but actually just using the evo herb basket.

It was and thats my mistake. i did not know the evo herb basket worked that way untill it was pointed out to me as i did not read this entire post until know. I had only read the first initial post with the rules and such and even after re reading it i found i had missed a few lines

We are currently collecting a group to test the depletion tools, let us know if you want to join the Coalition!

We welcome @redneck to the group!

Some thoughts and questions

*I am personally against depletion but this seems one sided. In the interest of the principle of balance, what can depleters do other than tp themselves somewhere else and still be movelocked or stay logged out to not get skill damaged until the curse is over? Sure there might ways to not be attacked but the best one isn't accessible to most (to my knowledge) And by the way if the depleter doesn't mind taking a break for however many hours this punishment does nothing unless you make it that the timer for the curse to be over is only counting while the account is online.

*CARD seems like a candidate for a new alliance. It's interesting to see people from all different lands have joined. Is dedication to an realm wide cause not sort of a conflict of interest with dedication to your own land?

* with the new recent changes to the game where resource collection and processing is becoming essential to the economy and getting gear and can contribute to cool stuff from evo shop and the forge - if jail or something else is not on the table, and skill damage must be a thing, shouldn't resource collection skills be the target of the skill damage instead of combat?

And when say for example your waterhandling drops to 0, your water bucket has a very high cooldown or maybe you can't collect at all and you have to retrain it somehow just to get back to 1. Just makes more sense to me.

Edited Sunday at 02:25 PM3 days by Sir Blut

I think the number of casts per item will need to be adjusted once the population increases again. Maybe there can be a sliding scale linked to the population?

I think people underestimate how much damage a single dedicated depleter can do. I could drain the entire realm by myself within a week, save for the 800 wiiya spot. After that keeping it at 0 is easy. There needs to be a counter.

The 800 wiiya and the 1000 hardwood lumber are the only two spots that might put up a fight

1 hour ago, Fang Archbane said:

The 800 wiiya and the 1000 hardwood lumber are the only two spots that might put up a fight

The 300 mineral ore was difficult until I stepped in.

We got one "person" out the working the loop holes to continue aiding in the depletion.

8 hours ago, Sir Blut said:

*CARD seems like a candidate for a new alliance. It's interesting to see people from all different lands have joined. Is dedication to an realm wide cause not sort of a conflict of interest with dedication to your own land?

Lands have always worked together to achieve things.

7 hours ago, Nep said:

I think people underestimate how much damage a single dedicated depleter can do. I could drain the entire realm by myself within a week, save for the 800 wiiya spot. After that keeping it at 0 is easy. There needs to be a counter.

Show us :)

7 hours ago, Chewett said:

Show us :)

Such conduct would be unbecoming of a member of GotR.