Here is my opinion on each of the previous rewards
Firstly i think these rewards should stay, as they seem
Best Back Story
Best Role Play
Best Personal Papers
Best Villain
Best Techie
Best LHO - seems an ok reward
Outstanding Service to MD
Rookie of the Year
Best Protector
Best Protector
Best PWR - I think should be removed so we dont just have a best Pwr and we have more larger catagories that would fit into this, like Roleplay, Papers and Back story
Best RPC - obviously should be removed
Most Addicted, Best Quote- there have been few quotes added, so i feel this should also be removed
Best Dojo Staff - There has been no real "SG" movement like the dojo was, it seems to have failed a bit more than the dojo did, due to Shadows lack of time, This is why i think the reward will only bring out people who want to try and win it
And finally, Guess who will complain about these rewards
Most Annoying, Least Convincing Alts - I do not see these are real rewards, it merely encourages something that i personally dont want to see, alts and annoying people. And also, these rewards are not likely to change over time, which means there will be continual rewards for these people. It was funny seeing people get them, but it seems pointless to have them again. They just seem to mock the other worthwhile rewards
So please, Iab and Lib come to defend those "rewards" i can see from your posts you only want to keep them, and i dont think they are real rewards in comparision and therefore should be removed.
Why create an award wherin you win all the time? It makes the entire rewards a laugh