So I guess that grace period isnt happening?

On 8/14/2026 at 7:32 AM, Chewett said:

Notes:

• I will start tracking marks in 1 weeks time for those who have not read read this post

• Resources that must be depleted to be gathered (memory stones, fenths) are allowed to be depleted

• Some leniency is given for when a tool gathers more than expected, please post below on a mark if you wish to appeal

As far as abiding by this disorganized approach, I refuse. I am not going to stop gathering resources as they become available while nothing meaningful is being done to address the underlying issue. None of these restrictions will stop Ledah from doing what he is doing. Until there is an actual solution in place, I will continue harvesting resources whenever I am able.

1 hour ago, Chewett said:

Sorry I don't know what you mean. I'm not aware of tools that do/don't deplete?

I think I know what this is about, please see below:

This seems to be a special case, I can demonstrate it to you in some scene if you want.

Edited August 18Aug 18 by jakubhi
(duplicate image)

1 minute ago, jakubhi said:

I think I know what this is about, please see below:

This seems to be a special case, I can demonstrate it to you in some scene if you want.

Nice! cool tool.

We will monitor for this :)

To clarify as someone pinged me asking whether the grace period exists:

• I will start tracking marks in 1 weeks time for those who have not read read this post

The grace period is 1 week so that those who don't read the post can have some leeway. If after a week you still don't know, that's probably on you.

The grace period does not apply to those who have read the post and continue to deplete, regardless of @Ledah claiming he didn't read it.

Hey, if you want to join CARD by blocking depleters I wrote a short guide!

7 hours ago, Chewett said:

Sorry I don't know what you mean. I'm not aware of tools that do/don't deplete?

I think they might be new. The herb basket I got from the evo store has this feature (and I just confirmed by harvesting from a location with less 0.5 resources and it remained at 0.5 resources).

Edited August 18Aug 18 by Ivorak
Oops, sorry for the duplicate info, I had an out of date thread loaded

Lovely to see more friends: https://forum.magicduel.com/topic/29107-joining-the-war-of-resources-on-the-side-of-card/#comment-206255

I hereby declare my loyalty to the cause of CARD.

The land gives us plenty. Let us work in community to make it so that everyone can have access to resources.

I will provide fellow members with heat stones to help fuel our spells.

Long live CARD!

@death ray @Else please note your depleting has garnered the attention of CARD

Do elaborate. My personal tools for collecting resources doesn't deplete them.

Also, I thought I was on your side. Was I not excepted into CARD??

Edited August 26Aug 26 by death ray

3 hours ago, death ray said:

Do elaborate. My personal tools for collecting resources doesn't deplete them.

Also, I thought I was on your side. Was I not excepted into CARD??

If you check here: https://forum.magicduel.com/topic/29102-known-depeleter-evidence-log-card/#findComment-206293

You can see that you gathered when there was 2 water left, you should have not done that.
You are still on our side but we must fairly track everyone reported
We only remove people from CARD by a vote of the members.

Thanks for being interested!

Again, personal tools don't take away from resources. I'm pretty sure of this. Herbs, .25/10 my personal tool still collects. My personal water bucket.... Water 1/10 remains 1/10 after use.

3 minutes ago, death ray said:

Again, personal tools don't take away from resources. I'm pretty sure of this. Herbs, .25/10 my personal tool still collects. My personal water bucket.... Water 1/10 remains 1/10 after use.

Was your personal water bucket from the evo shop?

My water bucket doesn't work when depleted and does take water away.

Could you try somewhere non-depleted and check before and after? I think we should remove your mark if you didn't know this

Example:

The herb basket from the evo shop does work like that however

As @death ray has reported his mistake and we now know what happened we have removed his mark!

We are a fair organisation, we will do this for anyone else who makes mistakes honestly

Yes, all tools I've referred to are from the Evo shop. So, as we currently know, Herb basket functions after depletion. Also noticed it doesn't take away prior to depletion.

@Fang Archbane has joined us

I stand with CARD.

Edited August 27Aug 27 by Fang Archbane

14 hours ago, Chewett said:

Was your personal water bucket from the evo shop?

My water bucket doesn't work when depleted and does take water away.

Could you try somewhere non-depleted and check before and after? I think we should remove your mark if you didn't know this

Example:

if its a bug let me know

@chew dont make code changes to md to fix anything, i am constantly uploading stuff over whats there

thx

6 hours ago, Muratus del Mur said:

if its a bug let me know

@chew dont make code changes to md to fix anything, i am constantly uploading stuff over whats there

thx

No bug and no code changes are being made to MD by me.

On 8/14/2026 at 6:32 AM, Chewett said:

Current Depleters:

• Seigheart - 25 marks

• Ledah - 23 marks

Current at risk

• Else - 1 mark

Goin to have to say nep needs added to depleting resources. I have witnessed Nep deplete the entire resource more than once today

1 hour ago, Blackshade Rider said:

Goin to have to say nep needs added to depleting resources. I have witnessed Nep deplete the entire resource more than once today

You need to read this thread more thoroughly as it explains this already. It's been noted that the EVO shop herbs basket does not deplete.

Can we get our tallys updated? Seems unfair to those trying to win first place...

8 hours ago, Blackshade Rider said:

Goin to have to say nep needs added to depleting resources. I have witnessed Nep deplete the entire resource more than once today

If you find these instances please post on the evidence thread.

But I suspect this is not actual depleting but actually just using the evo herb basket.

I'v opened up a new vote on some changes to the rules, if you think you are a member and don't have a PM tell me!