Okay here is a log of attacks.... Towards the end I started copying the text from the Ritual screen that says how much honor you should get, etc...
I started off with my win/loss ratio, honor, loyalty. Then I logged the attack and refreshed noting the new win/loss ratio, honor, loyalty.
Won: 273 | Lost: 491
Honor: 5000
Loyalty: 133
Attacked sioux...
WINNER enemy gets a loss
0% vs 100%
*** Combat details (under construction). 'E' is defender, 'A' is attacker
Your honor reward for this battle: 0
Your loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Enemy honor reward for this battle: -17 (This is supposed to be enemy honor, but notice here, and look below at MY honor penalization)
Enemy loyalty reward for this battle: 0
You were penalised with 3 honor for loosing this fight (I was penalized 17 not 3)
Won: 273 | Lost: 491
Honor: 4983
Loyalty: 133
Attacked Sacophilz...
WINNER
0% vs 100%
Combat details (under construction). 'A' is you, 'E' is enemy
Honor reward for this battle: -132 (Correct)
Loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Enemy was penalised with 3 honor for loosing this fight
Won: 273 | Lost: 491
Honor: 4851 (Correct)
Loyalty: 133
Attacked Manweor...
WINNER enemy gets a loss
4% vs 100%
Combat details (under construction). 'A' is you, 'E' is enemy
Honor reward for this battle: -81 (Correct)
Loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Enemy was penalised with 4 honor for loosing this fight
Won: 273 | Lost: 491
Honor: 4770 (Correct)
Loyalty: 133
Attacked Laz...
~~VICTORIOUS!~~
20% vs 98%
Combat details (under construction). 'A' is you, 'E' is enemy
Honor reward for this battle: -8 (Correct)
Loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Enemy was penalised with 5 honor for loosing this fight
Won: 273 | Lost: 491
Honor: 4762 (Correct)
Loyalty: 133
Attacked Graziel...
WINNER
0% vs 100%
Combat details (under construction). 'A' is you, 'E' is enemy
Honor reward for this battle: 166 (Correct)
Loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Enemy was penalised with 5 honor for loosing this fight
Won: 273 | Lost: 491
Honor: 4928 (Correct)
Loyalty: 133
Attacked Ghost Hunter...
You Retreated
79% vs 54%
Combat details (under construction). 'A' is you, 'E' is enemy
Honor reward for this battle: 0 (Correct)
Loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Won: 273 | Lost: 491
Honor: 4928 (Correct)
Loyalty: 133
Attacked by Thrall... (Was attacked by Thrall here, looks ok to me?)
~~VICTORIOUS!~~
22% vs 80%
*** Combat details (under construction). 'E' is defender, 'A' is attacker
Your honor reward for this battle: 0 (Correct)
Your loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Enemy honor reward for this battle: 0
Enemy loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Won: 273 | Lost: 491
Honor: 4928 (Correct)
Loyalty: 133
_______ Here is the log change where I copied info from Ritual page______
*** Attacking thrall ***
You will get 168 honor points if you win this fight
You will get loyalty points if you win this fight
WINNER
0% vs 100%
Combat details (under construction). 'A' is you, 'E' is enemy
Honor reward for this battle: 166 (Discrepancy of 2 points)
Loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Won: 273 | Lost: 491
Honor: 5000 (Correct - due to max)
Loyalty: 133
*** Attacking sioux ***
You will get -18 honor points if you win this fight
You will get loyalty points if you win this fight
WINNER
13% vs 100%
Combat details (under construction). 'A' is you, 'E' is enemy
Honor reward for this battle: -18 (Correct)
Loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Enemy was penalised with 5 honor for loosing this fight
Won: 273 | Lost: 491
Honor: 4982 (Correct)
Loyalty: 133
*** Attacking Sacosphilz ***
You will get -133 honor points if you win this fight
You will get loyalty points if you win this fight
WINNER
0% vs 100%
Combat details (under construction). 'A' is you, 'E' is enemy
Honor reward for this battle: -133 (Correct)
Loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Enemy was penalised with 2 honor for loosing this fight
Won: 273 | Lost: 491
Honor: 4849 (Correct)
Loyalty: 133
*** Attacking Manweor ***
You will get -82 honor points if you win this fight
You will get loyalty points if you win this fight
WINNER
2% vs 100%
Combat details (under construction). 'A' is you, 'E' is enemy
Honor reward for this battle: -82 (Correct)
Loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Enemy was penalised with 2 honor for loosing this fight
Won: 273 | Lost: 491
Honor: 4767 (Correct)
Loyalty: 133
*** Attacking Laz ***
You will get -8 honor points if you win this fight
You will get loyalty points if you win this fight
~~VICTORIOUS!~~
26% vs 70%
Combat details (under construction). 'A' is you, 'E' is enemy
Honor reward for this battle: -8 (Correct)
Loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Enemy was penalised with 5 honor for loosing this fight
Won: 273 | Lost: 491
Honor: 4759 (Correct)
Loyalty: 133
*** Attacking Korp ***
You will get -11 honor points if you win this fight
You will get loyalty points if you win this fight
You Retreated
60% vs 50%
Combat details (under construction). 'A' is you, 'E' is enemy
Honor reward for this battle: 0 (Discrepancy - no change)
Loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Won: 273 | Lost: 491
Honor: 4759 (Discrepancy - no change)
Loyalty: 133
*** Attacking dst *** (Alliance member test)
You will get -84 honor points if you win this fight
You will get loyalty points if you win this fight
~~DEFEATED~~
100% vs 0%
Combat details (under construction). 'A' is you, 'E' is enemy
Honor reward for this battle: 0 (Discrepancy - no change)
Loyalty reward for this battle: 0
You were penalised with 1 loyalty for loosing this fight
Won: 273 | Lost: 491
Honor: 4759 (Discrepancy - no change)
Loyalty: 133 (Discrepancy - no change)
Attacked by Siul...
You Retreated enemy gets a victory
84% vs 43%
*** Combat details (under construction). 'E' is defender, 'A' is attacker
Your honor reward for this battle: 0
Your loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Enemy honor reward for this battle: -61
Enemy loyalty reward for this battle: 0
You were penalised with 5 honor for loosing this fight (Correct)
Won: 273 | Lost: 491
Honor: 4754 (Correct)
Loyalty: 133
So for the moment the Win/loss and Loyalty counters do not move at all... just the honor.
This has changed since yesterday when I was clearly showing LOSSES on my battle counter
Edit: I just attacked Shoeps and got my Loss counter to increase by one....
~~DEFEATED~~ enemy gets a victory
100% vs -18%
*** Combat details (under construction). 'E' is defender, 'A' is attacker
Your honor reward for this battle: 0
Your loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Enemy honor reward for this battle: 0
Enemy loyalty reward for this battle: 0
Enemy was penalised with 1 loyalty for loosing this fight (I lost, so I should be penalised)
Won: 273 | Lost: 492
Honor: 3668
Loyalty: 134 (<--- error)
Now the interesting part here is that not only did my loss counter increase by one, BUT my Loyalty increase by one as well...